Wow...it is quiet here...Mark, what are you up to these days?
Original Post
The traffic here has almost come to a halt. I guess everyone is busy and AF4 is working well! Mark, how are you doing? What are you up to these days?
Best wishes,
-David
Best wishes,
-David
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Several posts every day isn't quite "halt". I notice Mark updated the To Think About box.
Reply by David Drake
Okay -- not exactly halt....but is has been slower than usual....and was just wondering what Mark was up to....
-David
-David
Reply by Jim (Atlanta)
I'm betting AF4 has done the trick for most folks and he's figuring out a way to present it in a book/video format to make some $.
Just a guess...
Just a guess...
Reply by Mike
It is an internet thing. There has to be a critical mass of posts to keep things flowing. Notice that when a bunch of us post then lots of others chime in. When there is not enough going on to interest us, the others don't have anything to respond to. It is self-perpetuating. If one or two of us stop chattering about the GED program, things will fall very silent again.
Reply by anon
I think your. He's tested something out on a willing audience and now its time to make some money.
Reply by Man of Kent
The ride's been great. Suspect it's over.
Reply by TK
While I do think the ride may be over as far as time management is concerned, as many people (me excluded) have selected AF4 as the ultimate. there is much terrain yet to be covered. For example, the Dreams book which doesn't get much play on here. It is great to be able to objectively choose your activities as in AF4, but what about selecting goals in the first place? What about the Dreams concept of self-coaching?
Reply by JD
TK: Indeed, "Dreams" was an intriguing book, it resonated with me far more than many of the other stuff out there. The self coaching, the what's better list, the present reality - all very original and fresh thinking in a sea of SMART goal-oriented material we see all the time.
I too hope there is a revival in this area. My coach needs coaching!
I too hope there is a revival in this area. My coach needs coaching!
Reply by Anon (Again)
I for one need to spend less time obsessing about "how to achieve" and spend more time "actually achieving" at the moment that actually means working out "what" it is I want to achieve. The Internet now eats away as much of my time as the TV used to.
Reply by Renfrew
This has been an amazing forum. I learned a lot here and AF4 is a great tool.
BUT: I have the feeling we are working at the "low end" of things. What about dreams of the great life, inspiring goals, how to find and clarify goals etc.? This is FAR more important imho than any time management "technique" (while no doubt useful).
Renfrew
BUT: I have the feeling we are working at the "low end" of things. What about dreams of the great life, inspiring goals, how to find and clarify goals etc.? This is FAR more important imho than any time management "technique" (while no doubt useful).
Renfrew
Reply by learning as I go
Hi all
It's possible that Mark has grown weary of AF discussions or time management period but he's too kind to shoo us off! *blush*
I pray that there's no health issue.
learning as I go
It's possible that Mark has grown weary of AF discussions or time management period but he's too kind to shoo us off! *blush*
I pray that there's no health issue.
learning as I go
Reply by Walter
Hi,
Even if Mark's participation is reduced, aren't there still things to discuss? Software implementations, tweaks, support for new users...
I miss the posts from some users that are missing: ChristineB, Jacqueline and others (and of course, Mark's himself).
Even if Mark's participation is reduced, aren't there still things to discuss? Software implementations, tweaks, support for new users...
I miss the posts from some users that are missing: ChristineB, Jacqueline and others (and of course, Mark's himself).
Reply by David Drake
I agree -- and Mark -- are you there? Why no comment?
-David
-David
Reply by Mark Forster
David:
Yes, I'm here. But I'm retired these days so my participation is limited.
Yes, I'm here. But I'm retired these days so my participation is limited.
Reply by Jacqueline
Hi Walter - thanks! You made my day. :-)
I'm not using AF4 or any version of AF at the moment - but am using many of the principles - standing out, little and often, etc. and DIT (w/current initiatives on steroids) - so there hasn't been much for me to talk about as you guys have gone into technical stuff about lists and such. And I've been super busy and (mostly) super motivated, I guess. I'm still keeping lists, but not the same way.
Like Renfrew and Anon (Again) above, I'm more into the "what" am I doing, rather than the "how".
There's always the danger for me of getting better, stronger, faster at stuff that really isn't that important in the grand scheme of things. So I've been playing around with methods of putting more emphasis on what's important to me and less of what isn't. Although it shouldn't be, it really is kind of difficult. ;-)
I'm not using AF4 or any version of AF at the moment - but am using many of the principles - standing out, little and often, etc. and DIT (w/current initiatives on steroids) - so there hasn't been much for me to talk about as you guys have gone into technical stuff about lists and such. And I've been super busy and (mostly) super motivated, I guess. I'm still keeping lists, but not the same way.
Like Renfrew and Anon (Again) above, I'm more into the "what" am I doing, rather than the "how".
There's always the danger for me of getting better, stronger, faster at stuff that really isn't that important in the grand scheme of things. So I've been playing around with methods of putting more emphasis on what's important to me and less of what isn't. Although it shouldn't be, it really is kind of difficult. ;-)
Reply by Laurence
Welcome back, Jacqueline. Yes, I suspect AF 4.5 may deal with giving a little more directed attention to major projects. I am still putting everything into AF4, though Mike and others have dealt with this issue (correct me if I'm wrong, Mike) by filtering what actually gets in to the list in the first place, so the lawn mower runs faster.
Perhaps AF4.5 might be a two tiered system, with most of the time spent processing things in a primary tier. Or a notebook with two ends, with a mechanism for copying primary tasks from the everything end to the executable end.
Is anyone else finding it is gradually taking longer to draw the next line, or is it just me?
I hasten to add that I really like AF4, and it truly appeals to me. I just do not yet feel it is Nirvana. But for that one supposedly has to sit still and beam. A different concept.
Perhaps AF4.5 might be a two tiered system, with most of the time spent processing things in a primary tier. Or a notebook with two ends, with a mechanism for copying primary tasks from the everything end to the executable end.
Is anyone else finding it is gradually taking longer to draw the next line, or is it just me?
I hasten to add that I really like AF4, and it truly appeals to me. I just do not yet feel it is Nirvana. But for that one supposedly has to sit still and beam. A different concept.
Reply by JD
Laurence & Jacqueline : All very important and good points, definitely. I don't have difficulty drawing the line, and have settled to using AF2 which deals very nicely for the faster pace I am faced with. If the back portions are not adequately dealt with, the threat of dismissal of a large block of tasks does its work in maintaining my discipline.
The problem I do have is wondering whether I have a compass. Am I doing the task in accordance with my desired goals? I know these are questions I should pose in AF itself, and allow my thoughts to develop over time. I don't spend enough time working on the concepts in "Dreams", I know that.
But I'd rather just live with this angst and allowing AF to bring this up for me to work on, rather than tweaking the system drastically to fit any self perceived notions of a lack in my daily work.
The problem I do have is wondering whether I have a compass. Am I doing the task in accordance with my desired goals? I know these are questions I should pose in AF itself, and allow my thoughts to develop over time. I don't spend enough time working on the concepts in "Dreams", I know that.
But I'd rather just live with this angst and allowing AF to bring this up for me to work on, rather than tweaking the system drastically to fit any self perceived notions of a lack in my daily work.
Reply by Mark Forster
To expand on what I said on another thread yesterday:
The name Autofocus comes from photography. Most modern cameras don't just have autofocus, they also automatically adjust the aperture, shutter speed, ISO and colour balance, and sometimes a lot more as well. They make it much easier for you to do your job - which is to point the camera in the right direction.
It's the same with AFs 1-4. They are tools which will make it much easier for you to do your work, but you still have to point yourself in the right direction.
The name Autofocus comes from photography. Most modern cameras don't just have autofocus, they also automatically adjust the aperture, shutter speed, ISO and colour balance, and sometimes a lot more as well. They make it much easier for you to do your job - which is to point the camera in the right direction.
It's the same with AFs 1-4. They are tools which will make it much easier for you to do your work, but you still have to point yourself in the right direction.
Reply by Mike
Good Morning Laurence,
<<< Welcome back, Jacqueline. <<<
YES! We've missed you!
>>> Yes, I suspect AF 4.5 may deal with giving a little more directed attention to major projects. I am still putting everything into AF4, though Mike and others have dealt with this issue (correct me if I'm wrong, Mike) by filtering what actually gets in to the list in the first place, so the lawn mower runs faster. <<<
Basically, you are right, but it comes down to terminology. I have settled on putting EVERYTHING in my AF book, but is that really AF if I immediately delete things ... which I do. Or does it become AF once the first deltions take place? I'm not sure we need an AF 4.5. I think it becomes a question of using the system in the way that works best for you.
I like Mark's analogy to a camera. You really do have to decide what you want to take the picture of before you let the camera do it's magic and adjust the focus for you. I do not think that has to be built into AF as we know it now. I think you do that FIRST, and then use AF to execute.
It is the same with scheduling. As I have said, I cull out urgent items and run them from a list EXTERNAL to AF, then do AF when I'm not attending to them. Can AF do that for me? Well, not for me, but obviously for Mark and others. But I have no angst about it. The point is to not keep a system "pure" but to make the system ultimately vanish because it is just the way things get done for you.
>>> Perhaps AF4.5 might be a two tiered system, with most of the time spent processing things in a primary tier. Or a notebook with two ends, with a mechanism for copying primary tasks from the everything end to the executable end. <<<
Then my advise would be to just do that for yourself it it seems like it would work. If you want to know what works for me:
- Weekly review my short term goals in the context of my intermediate and long term goals,
- Derive a list of weekly goals from that review,
- Derive a list of tasks to accomplish those goals,
- Block time in the upcoming week to work on those tasks,
- Each day review my blocked time and urgent items and plan my day,
- Work that plan,
- When I think of things put them on the AF list,
- Decide if they WILL get done before the next review period,
- if not, delete them right then (to get them out of the road)
- Work the AF list when I'm not working my blocked time or urgent tasks.
As you can see, my direction comes from the weekly review. My focus comes from my task list first, my scheduled blocks of time second, then my AF list third.
>>> I hasten to add that I really like AF4, and it truly appeals to me. I just do not yet feel it is Nirvana. But for that one supposedly has to sit still and beam. A different concept. >>>
LOL ;-) I'd have to say that MY system is "nirvana". That is to say that I've fine tuned it and it works like a charm for me and my context. Were I suddenly to change my life style, I'd guess that my way of working would change to accommodate that.
<<< Welcome back, Jacqueline. <<<
YES! We've missed you!
>>> Yes, I suspect AF 4.5 may deal with giving a little more directed attention to major projects. I am still putting everything into AF4, though Mike and others have dealt with this issue (correct me if I'm wrong, Mike) by filtering what actually gets in to the list in the first place, so the lawn mower runs faster. <<<
Basically, you are right, but it comes down to terminology. I have settled on putting EVERYTHING in my AF book, but is that really AF if I immediately delete things ... which I do. Or does it become AF once the first deltions take place? I'm not sure we need an AF 4.5. I think it becomes a question of using the system in the way that works best for you.
I like Mark's analogy to a camera. You really do have to decide what you want to take the picture of before you let the camera do it's magic and adjust the focus for you. I do not think that has to be built into AF as we know it now. I think you do that FIRST, and then use AF to execute.
It is the same with scheduling. As I have said, I cull out urgent items and run them from a list EXTERNAL to AF, then do AF when I'm not attending to them. Can AF do that for me? Well, not for me, but obviously for Mark and others. But I have no angst about it. The point is to not keep a system "pure" but to make the system ultimately vanish because it is just the way things get done for you.
>>> Perhaps AF4.5 might be a two tiered system, with most of the time spent processing things in a primary tier. Or a notebook with two ends, with a mechanism for copying primary tasks from the everything end to the executable end. <<<
Then my advise would be to just do that for yourself it it seems like it would work. If you want to know what works for me:
- Weekly review my short term goals in the context of my intermediate and long term goals,
- Derive a list of weekly goals from that review,
- Derive a list of tasks to accomplish those goals,
- Block time in the upcoming week to work on those tasks,
- Each day review my blocked time and urgent items and plan my day,
- Work that plan,
- When I think of things put them on the AF list,
- Decide if they WILL get done before the next review period,
- if not, delete them right then (to get them out of the road)
- Work the AF list when I'm not working my blocked time or urgent tasks.
As you can see, my direction comes from the weekly review. My focus comes from my task list first, my scheduled blocks of time second, then my AF list third.
>>> I hasten to add that I really like AF4, and it truly appeals to me. I just do not yet feel it is Nirvana. But for that one supposedly has to sit still and beam. A different concept. >>>
LOL ;-) I'd have to say that MY system is "nirvana". That is to say that I've fine tuned it and it works like a charm for me and my context. Were I suddenly to change my life style, I'd guess that my way of working would change to accommodate that.
Reply by Mark Forster
I think to use the camera analogy again, you have to give the camera something to focus on!
Reply by Nicole
Point taken, Mark!
Question for me remains, how to make sure you spend some time thinking about what your own "right direction" is. I've found that the dismissal process in AF1-4 helps a lot to sift out the stuff that's the wrong direction; but I've still got to figure out a way to think more or less systematically about what my right direction is. I've tried writing down goals periodically in the past, but reviewing them was always very discouraging so I stopped doing that. Any pointers on how to go about formulating goals, and stick to using them as compass, would be very helpful!
Question for me remains, how to make sure you spend some time thinking about what your own "right direction" is. I've found that the dismissal process in AF1-4 helps a lot to sift out the stuff that's the wrong direction; but I've still got to figure out a way to think more or less systematically about what my right direction is. I've tried writing down goals periodically in the past, but reviewing them was always very discouraging so I stopped doing that. Any pointers on how to go about formulating goals, and stick to using them as compass, would be very helpful!
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Pick one goal, put it on your list. Work on the goal as AF brings you to it.
Work on that goal consists of: (1) making sure that's really your goal, (2) thinking (planning) about how to get to that goal. This planning will be in a separate goal-planning page/folder. (3) Adding initial tasks relating to your goal into the AF list. The goal itself can be taken off the list now if the tasks cover it.
When you finish a goal-related task, think if there's another goal-related task that needs to be added to the list, and add it.
Work on that goal consists of: (1) making sure that's really your goal, (2) thinking (planning) about how to get to that goal. This planning will be in a separate goal-planning page/folder. (3) Adding initial tasks relating to your goal into the AF list. The goal itself can be taken off the list now if the tasks cover it.
When you finish a goal-related task, think if there's another goal-related task that needs to be added to the list, and add it.
Reply by Mike
Nicole,
Why has reviewing been discouraging? I would find goal review discouraging if I did not do it weekly, for example. The point of reviewing goals is to make course corrections when you can do something to change the outcome. I found that only weekly reviews makes sense.
What gives goals power is the reason you set them. So it helps if you know exactly why you want your goals and to keep that reason right in front of you. An example, perhaps?
Long Term Goal: "Climb Mt. Everest.
Reason: "To see the world from one of the highest places and feel the sense of excitement that comes from doing that."
Intermediate Goal: "Climb Mt. McKinley"
Short Term Goals: (One Month to One Year)
- Find Schools
- Join Health Club
- Buy Climbing Gear
Next Weeks Tasks:
- Call Health Clubs
- Buy Climbing Books
- Subscribe to Climbing Magazines
So I'm set for the next week. A week goes by and I review, Suppose I did none of my tasks this week. What is the worst that I'll feel? I'll feel only slightly disspaointed and I've not done irreversable damage to my goals because it is only three small tasks and one week lost. Very recoverable. I feel more motivated than ever.
Contrast that with not breaking it down to small tasks and short term goals and reviewing only monthly or yearly. Then I would feel very badly because the loss would be greater.
So my suggestion is that you pick ONE lifetime goal and break it down until you reach the one week tasks stage then review weely and each weekly review see the progress you have made and create more tasks to help you get to your short term goal.
If you get more ambitious, work through the exercises in this book:
http://www.amazon.com/Control-Your-Time-Life-Signet/dp/0451167724/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1257861408&sr=1-1
Why has reviewing been discouraging? I would find goal review discouraging if I did not do it weekly, for example. The point of reviewing goals is to make course corrections when you can do something to change the outcome. I found that only weekly reviews makes sense.
What gives goals power is the reason you set them. So it helps if you know exactly why you want your goals and to keep that reason right in front of you. An example, perhaps?
Long Term Goal: "Climb Mt. Everest.
Reason: "To see the world from one of the highest places and feel the sense of excitement that comes from doing that."
Intermediate Goal: "Climb Mt. McKinley"
Short Term Goals: (One Month to One Year)
- Find Schools
- Join Health Club
- Buy Climbing Gear
Next Weeks Tasks:
- Call Health Clubs
- Buy Climbing Books
- Subscribe to Climbing Magazines
So I'm set for the next week. A week goes by and I review, Suppose I did none of my tasks this week. What is the worst that I'll feel? I'll feel only slightly disspaointed and I've not done irreversable damage to my goals because it is only three small tasks and one week lost. Very recoverable. I feel more motivated than ever.
Contrast that with not breaking it down to small tasks and short term goals and reviewing only monthly or yearly. Then I would feel very badly because the loss would be greater.
So my suggestion is that you pick ONE lifetime goal and break it down until you reach the one week tasks stage then review weely and each weekly review see the progress you have made and create more tasks to help you get to your short term goal.
If you get more ambitious, work through the exercises in this book:
http://www.amazon.com/Control-Your-Time-Life-Signet/dp/0451167724/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1257861408&sr=1-1
Reply by avrum
I've been using AF4, consistently, for a few weeks now. I have no desire to read another TM book, and/or adopt another TM program. I can't recall the last time I felt this way. The only question that remains is, will "... will I have the courage to take actions on my convictions?." - Dr. M Bowen
Reply by Jacqueline
Hi Nicole,
It sounds like you're getting discouraged because you think your progress *should* be further ahead? Or you're comparing yourself to the ideal maybe?
I think most people overestimate how much progress we can make on goals and still have a normal life. Part of that's probably related to media etc. - ie. people on the Biggest Loser can lose 20 pounds a week, so I can't be happy with my measly one pound.
I think Alan's way of adding tasks to the list above can work really well for some people. I know that I work a little better having one major focus for the month or a "season". Like many people who write a novel in a month on nanowrimo - they gear their every spare moment to writing that book.
I'd start my list by watching the movie "The Bucket List" - the whole thing is posted on youtube.
Then I'd follow a simple system like this:
http://www.squidoo.com/100things
And see what really pops out at you to add to your AF list. The one that makes you go WOW, I'd LOVE to do that. You could also find a picture or piece of writing that represents that to go in your book.
I wouldn't focus on the measuring myself against where I think I should be then as long as I'm following a good process. How do you really know how far you *should* get if you've never done it before?
It sounds like you're getting discouraged because you think your progress *should* be further ahead? Or you're comparing yourself to the ideal maybe?
I think most people overestimate how much progress we can make on goals and still have a normal life. Part of that's probably related to media etc. - ie. people on the Biggest Loser can lose 20 pounds a week, so I can't be happy with my measly one pound.
I think Alan's way of adding tasks to the list above can work really well for some people. I know that I work a little better having one major focus for the month or a "season". Like many people who write a novel in a month on nanowrimo - they gear their every spare moment to writing that book.
I'd start my list by watching the movie "The Bucket List" - the whole thing is posted on youtube.
Then I'd follow a simple system like this:
http://www.squidoo.com/100things
And see what really pops out at you to add to your AF list. The one that makes you go WOW, I'd LOVE to do that. You could also find a picture or piece of writing that represents that to go in your book.
I wouldn't focus on the measuring myself against where I think I should be then as long as I'm following a good process. How do you really know how far you *should* get if you've never done it before?
Reply by Jacqueline
Forgot to mention this is also a neat concept of 101 things in 1001 days:
http://www.dayzeroproject.com/
:
http://www.dayzeroproject.com/
:
Reply by Lillian
Jacqueline said >>I wouldn't focus on the measuring myself against where I think I should be then as long as I'm following a good process.<<
that's the problem I have with SMART goals where T is the time - if you set a goal to do X by date Y, it's not hard to see when it's not going to happen by that time for whatever reason. So you change the date to Y+3months. Or the goal to X-15%. Either way you set up the mindset that you "never" reach your goals, so why bother? (and by 'you' I mean a generic you, not anyone specifically)
that's the problem I have with SMART goals where T is the time - if you set a goal to do X by date Y, it's not hard to see when it's not going to happen by that time for whatever reason. So you change the date to Y+3months. Or the goal to X-15%. Either way you set up the mindset that you "never" reach your goals, so why bother? (and by 'you' I mean a generic you, not anyone specifically)
Reply by Mark Forster
Nicole:
<< how to make sure you spend some time thinking about what your own "right direction" is. >>
The simple answer is to make it a task in AF. You can put whatever reviews or visioning sessions you like into your AF list.
On the general subject of goal setting, there are a lot of articles on this site about it. Have a look through the Blog Category "Getting to Your Goals":
http://www.markforster.net/blog/category/getting-to-your-goals
<< how to make sure you spend some time thinking about what your own "right direction" is. >>
The simple answer is to make it a task in AF. You can put whatever reviews or visioning sessions you like into your AF list.
On the general subject of goal setting, there are a lot of articles on this site about it. Have a look through the Blog Category "Getting to Your Goals":
http://www.markforster.net/blog/category/getting-to-your-goals
Reply by Nicole
Wow, thanks for all the replies!
My problem with reviewing goals is that because I don't review them regularly, it's disappointing to see how little progress I've made when I do review them. Or sometimes I've even totally abandoned a goal without realizing it at the time. That suggested to me that I haven't been writing done my "right" goals, but as I already wrote, for some reason I never get around to really thinking about my "right" goals. Making it a task in AF hasn't helped so far, probably because I'm a bit uncomfortable thinking about goals, and not knowing how to start makes me skip over the task "review goals" until it's dismissed. Maybe I should just have a go at one or two methods suggested here, and put those in AF to see how that works out.
Anyway, thanks for all the suggestions, I'll post back here about my progress!
My problem with reviewing goals is that because I don't review them regularly, it's disappointing to see how little progress I've made when I do review them. Or sometimes I've even totally abandoned a goal without realizing it at the time. That suggested to me that I haven't been writing done my "right" goals, but as I already wrote, for some reason I never get around to really thinking about my "right" goals. Making it a task in AF hasn't helped so far, probably because I'm a bit uncomfortable thinking about goals, and not knowing how to start makes me skip over the task "review goals" until it's dismissed. Maybe I should just have a go at one or two methods suggested here, and put those in AF to see how that works out.
Anyway, thanks for all the suggestions, I'll post back here about my progress!
Reply by Sherminator
The Pomodoro Technique + Problem Solving 101 (Ken Wanatabe) = powerful combination.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Hey Nicole,
Start small! If you have more than a very few goals going at once , you'll inevitably find you aren't making much progress on any of them. Read the Power of Less blog/book referenced in another thread. It's very good about goals.
What I learned from that: Look at all your potential goals and choose the One you really want to do first. If it's a big goal, define smaller subgoals. Make sure you truly get started towards that goal.
Feel free to pursue more than one goal, but if you want to see progress, don't do too many at once.
Start small! If you have more than a very few goals going at once , you'll inevitably find you aren't making much progress on any of them. Read the Power of Less blog/book referenced in another thread. It's very good about goals.
What I learned from that: Look at all your potential goals and choose the One you really want to do first. If it's a big goal, define smaller subgoals. Make sure you truly get started towards that goal.
Feel free to pursue more than one goal, but if you want to see progress, don't do too many at once.
Reply by Mark Forster
Remember it's better to do a few things well than a lot of things badly.
Reply by Mark Forster
Nineteen posts on this thread so far today. Is it time to rename it?
Reply by David Drake
Hmmm....maybe so....guess things have sped up here considerably....
-David
-David
Reply by Jacqueline
Well, it WAS quiet here, but then this goal stuff started up again... it brings the yappy ones out of the woodwork. :-)
Nicole, I really like this concept of sprinting towards a goal:
http://geniuscatalyst.com/geniusblog/2009/07/mnct-668-the-art-of-sprinting/
Like Alan says, I would just pick one - for one thing it's so much easier to focus on one goal and make sure steps towards it stay on your list. If you're actively working on it, you shouldn't really have to review your progress if that makes you uncomfortable. It will take as long as it takes, and that's okay.
There are also some goals that I have that I like to do on auto-pilot. If you set up a structure to your life that they just happen automatically, this should be easy. A certain amount of money going to savings, a time to exercise, Friday night date nights, etc.
The other thing I've found is that once you've written things down, your "reticular activating system" will go to work for you to "filter in" opportunities. On my goals list 5 years ago was to live in a house with a library and a wood burning fireplace. I'm not a believer in the law of attraction, but not too long after writing that down, I did find a house that had both of those features - in the same room. Would I have found it without defining some of the things I wanted? Maybe.
I think of listing goals as something really fun to do every once in awhile and it at least gives you a starting point, even if you don't actively manage them. Even if you do something as simple as list the places that you'd like to see one day, the next time you plan your vacation, instead of just mindlessly choosing a place to go based on where your friends would go or the ads you get from travel places online, you can instead look at your list at all the places *you* REALLY want to see and choose something from there.
All the best and good luck!
Nicole, I really like this concept of sprinting towards a goal:
http://geniuscatalyst.com/geniusblog/2009/07/mnct-668-the-art-of-sprinting/
Like Alan says, I would just pick one - for one thing it's so much easier to focus on one goal and make sure steps towards it stay on your list. If you're actively working on it, you shouldn't really have to review your progress if that makes you uncomfortable. It will take as long as it takes, and that's okay.
There are also some goals that I have that I like to do on auto-pilot. If you set up a structure to your life that they just happen automatically, this should be easy. A certain amount of money going to savings, a time to exercise, Friday night date nights, etc.
The other thing I've found is that once you've written things down, your "reticular activating system" will go to work for you to "filter in" opportunities. On my goals list 5 years ago was to live in a house with a library and a wood burning fireplace. I'm not a believer in the law of attraction, but not too long after writing that down, I did find a house that had both of those features - in the same room. Would I have found it without defining some of the things I wanted? Maybe.
I think of listing goals as something really fun to do every once in awhile and it at least gives you a starting point, even if you don't actively manage them. Even if you do something as simple as list the places that you'd like to see one day, the next time you plan your vacation, instead of just mindlessly choosing a place to go based on where your friends would go or the ads you get from travel places online, you can instead look at your list at all the places *you* REALLY want to see and choose something from there.
All the best and good luck!
Reply by Jacqueline
Lillian, I totally agree with you on the time thing with respect to goals. So many of my goals are things I've never done before or have factors somewhat beyond my control, so how can the time to complete them be estimated?
It reminds me of when my oldest kid was little and I would look at the medical books for the time he *should* start walking or talking and I'd be stressed out when it didn't happen on schedule. But it happened when it happened. I could have saved myself some anxiety by not worrying about it.
I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating. Yeah, if you're training for a marathon at a certain date, it's probably a good thing to have sub-goals that are broken down over time, but for most things, whether you get it done in one month or three, what's the big deal?
It reminds me of when my oldest kid was little and I would look at the medical books for the time he *should* start walking or talking and I'd be stressed out when it didn't happen on schedule. But it happened when it happened. I could have saved myself some anxiety by not worrying about it.
I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating. Yeah, if you're training for a marathon at a certain date, it's probably a good thing to have sub-goals that are broken down over time, but for most things, whether you get it done in one month or three, what's the big deal?
Reply by Laurence
Mark:
<>
It's because we're all so happy to see you back. That right, everyone?
What is this thing called retirement, anyway?
<
It's because we're all so happy to see you back. That right, everyone?
What is this thing called retirement, anyway?
Reply by Mark Forster
Laurence:
<< What is this thing called retirement, anyway? >>
It's one of my goals.
Hmm... now just how am I going to measure my progress? How many comments I *haven't* answered on this Forum perhaps?
<< What is this thing called retirement, anyway? >>
It's one of my goals.
Hmm... now just how am I going to measure my progress? How many comments I *haven't* answered on this Forum perhaps?
Reply by Mike
>>> that's the problem I have with SMART goals where T is the time - if you set a goal to do X by date Y, it's not hard to see when it's not going to happen by that time for whatever reason. So you change the date to Y+3months. Or the goal to X-15%. Either way you set up the mindset that you "never" reach your goals, so why bother? (and by 'you' I mean a generic you, not anyone specifically) <<<
We beat this idea to death some time ago, IIRC. The problem comes in when you see a goal as something static. A static goal is not all that useful. Feedback is an essential component of any goal seeking system. Goal seeking systems are a negative feedback loop. They contain a function where the distance to the goal is measured and the system is corrected to keep it on course. Without that, a goal is pointless.
And that is exactly why goals fail ... no feedback. We set a goal and don't review our progress and so wander off course. If you were to drive your car to a distant city and, when you started out, set out in the right direction then went to sleep ... well, I doubt you'd make it. Being just a little frustrated with lack of progress is not the problem ... it is an essential part of the solution. IOW, don't shoot the messenger. ;-)
We beat this idea to death some time ago, IIRC. The problem comes in when you see a goal as something static. A static goal is not all that useful. Feedback is an essential component of any goal seeking system. Goal seeking systems are a negative feedback loop. They contain a function where the distance to the goal is measured and the system is corrected to keep it on course. Without that, a goal is pointless.
And that is exactly why goals fail ... no feedback. We set a goal and don't review our progress and so wander off course. If you were to drive your car to a distant city and, when you started out, set out in the right direction then went to sleep ... well, I doubt you'd make it. Being just a little frustrated with lack of progress is not the problem ... it is an essential part of the solution. IOW, don't shoot the messenger. ;-)
Reply by Mike
Nicole,
>>> My problem with reviewing goals is that because I don't review them regularly, it's disappointing to see how little progress I've made when I do review them. <<<
So there is where I'd suggest you start ... WHY don't you review them regularly? I suspect that most often we don't review often is because we are not really committed to the goals in the first place. Maybe we have heard that we SHOULD have goals and so gin up some that are meaningless for us and the only thing we get from a review is guilt ... over not having done something we did not want to do in the first place.
Consider what I said earlier, and Alan just said here: start with only a single goal. The Alan Lakiein book describes how to completely analyze your desires and lay out a path for your entire life. That works for some but might intimidate others. If it intimidates you, then start with something you feel you really want that will take maybe a year or less. Then break that down into shorter subgaols then to tasks which can be accomplished in one week. Then in a week, review and set more week long tasks. If you missed the target for that week, do some real soul searching. Put the breaks on ... maybe even go on a retreat in necessary ... and find out WHY! Without learning why you are not succeeding in taking at least ONE small step toward what is most important to your life, you'll never have what is most important in your life.
>>> Or sometimes I've even totally abandoned a goal without realizing it at the time. That suggested to me that I haven't been writing done my "right" goals, but as I already wrote, for some reason I never get around to really thinking about my "right" goals. <<<
I believe that is correct. Try that Lakein exercise then. Basically it consists of writing down, as quickly as possible, everything that comes into your head in answer to several questions. Questions such as: "If there were no limits, what would I want to do with the rest of my life?" or "If I only had six months to live, how would I spend it?" The key is to keep writing as fast as you can without censoring ideas because they are "impossible" or "silly". Then, after waiting a day or so, going back to the list and analyzing it, grouping things into categories and trying to uncover what really lies beneath all of what you wrote. You WILL see some important yearnings. Those become your REAL goals.
>>> Making it a task in AF hasn't helped so far, probably because I'm a bit uncomfortable thinking about goals, and not knowing how to start makes me skip over the task "review goals" until it's dismissed. Maybe I should just have a go at one or two methods suggested here, and put those in AF to see how that works out. <<<
Accept failure as part of the process. Failure is the feedback we need to correct our course so that we can succeed. Failure is not something to be ashamed or even avoided. Paradoxically, failure is essential to achieve success.
>>> My problem with reviewing goals is that because I don't review them regularly, it's disappointing to see how little progress I've made when I do review them. <<<
So there is where I'd suggest you start ... WHY don't you review them regularly? I suspect that most often we don't review often is because we are not really committed to the goals in the first place. Maybe we have heard that we SHOULD have goals and so gin up some that are meaningless for us and the only thing we get from a review is guilt ... over not having done something we did not want to do in the first place.
Consider what I said earlier, and Alan just said here: start with only a single goal. The Alan Lakiein book describes how to completely analyze your desires and lay out a path for your entire life. That works for some but might intimidate others. If it intimidates you, then start with something you feel you really want that will take maybe a year or less. Then break that down into shorter subgaols then to tasks which can be accomplished in one week. Then in a week, review and set more week long tasks. If you missed the target for that week, do some real soul searching. Put the breaks on ... maybe even go on a retreat in necessary ... and find out WHY! Without learning why you are not succeeding in taking at least ONE small step toward what is most important to your life, you'll never have what is most important in your life.
>>> Or sometimes I've even totally abandoned a goal without realizing it at the time. That suggested to me that I haven't been writing done my "right" goals, but as I already wrote, for some reason I never get around to really thinking about my "right" goals. <<<
I believe that is correct. Try that Lakein exercise then. Basically it consists of writing down, as quickly as possible, everything that comes into your head in answer to several questions. Questions such as: "If there were no limits, what would I want to do with the rest of my life?" or "If I only had six months to live, how would I spend it?" The key is to keep writing as fast as you can without censoring ideas because they are "impossible" or "silly". Then, after waiting a day or so, going back to the list and analyzing it, grouping things into categories and trying to uncover what really lies beneath all of what you wrote. You WILL see some important yearnings. Those become your REAL goals.
>>> Making it a task in AF hasn't helped so far, probably because I'm a bit uncomfortable thinking about goals, and not knowing how to start makes me skip over the task "review goals" until it's dismissed. Maybe I should just have a go at one or two methods suggested here, and put those in AF to see how that works out. <<<
Accept failure as part of the process. Failure is the feedback we need to correct our course so that we can succeed. Failure is not something to be ashamed or even avoided. Paradoxically, failure is essential to achieve success.
Reply by Mark Forster
Great, that's two comments I haven't answered. Progress indeed!
Reply by Nicole
Hi Mike,
>>>
So there is where I'd suggest you start ... WHY don't you review them regularly? I suspect that most often we don't review often is because we are not really committed to the goals in the first place.
>>>
Right on! I'll have a look at the Lakiein book, thanks for the suggestion.
>>>
So there is where I'd suggest you start ... WHY don't you review them regularly? I suspect that most often we don't review often is because we are not really committed to the goals in the first place.
>>>
Right on! I'll have a look at the Lakiein book, thanks for the suggestion.
Reply by Lillian
Mike -
>>We beat this idea to death some time ago, IIRC. <<
Sorry about the resurrection, I'll go through and see if I can find the older posts.
>>The problem comes in when you see a goal as something static. A static goal is not all that useful. Feedback is an essential component of any goal seeking system. Goal seeking systems are a negative feedback loop. They contain a function where the distance to the goal is measured and the system is corrected to keep it on course. Without that, a goal is pointless.<<
But since we're here... If I set a goal of "Be in NewYork City this Saturday at 9am" I can spend the week planning the trip, packing, etc etc. Then sometimes comes up on Friday which makes "Saturday at 9am" unlikely. I change the goal to "Be in NewYork City this Sunday at 9am" Goal set. Feedback received. Goal changed.
But the original goal was not achieved. I am not in NYC Satuday.
If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date?
Jacqueline -
>>I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating.<<
Exactly - I need to get my head/motivation around this one. Yes, I want to redecorate my house (step 1 - tell dh :) ) but whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 or whatever doesn't really matter. Bobb Biehr (I think that's the spelling) wrote a book about solving problems instead of setting goals. I think I need to re-read that and see if I can incorporate some of his ideas.
>>We beat this idea to death some time ago, IIRC. <<
Sorry about the resurrection, I'll go through and see if I can find the older posts.
>>The problem comes in when you see a goal as something static. A static goal is not all that useful. Feedback is an essential component of any goal seeking system. Goal seeking systems are a negative feedback loop. They contain a function where the distance to the goal is measured and the system is corrected to keep it on course. Without that, a goal is pointless.<<
But since we're here... If I set a goal of "Be in NewYork City this Saturday at 9am" I can spend the week planning the trip, packing, etc etc. Then sometimes comes up on Friday which makes "Saturday at 9am" unlikely. I change the goal to "Be in NewYork City this Sunday at 9am" Goal set. Feedback received. Goal changed.
But the original goal was not achieved. I am not in NYC Satuday.
If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date?
Jacqueline -
>>I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating.<<
Exactly - I need to get my head/motivation around this one. Yes, I want to redecorate my house (step 1 - tell dh :) ) but whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 or whatever doesn't really matter. Bobb Biehr (I think that's the spelling) wrote a book about solving problems instead of setting goals. I think I need to re-read that and see if I can incorporate some of his ideas.
Reply by Mark Forster
Lilian:
<< If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date? >>
I think the example you give shows that a goal does need a date, because until you decide that you are going to be in NYC by 9am Saturday you won't take any action towards actually getting there, e.g. book plane tickets, arrange time off work, packing etc. The new time doesn't mean you have failed at your goal - it means you have to take some further actions, e.g. change travel arrangements, re-book housesitter, etc. Without the date you can neither take the first actions nor the subsequent ones.
You want to redecorate your house, but it doesn't matter whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or 2012? Well, it certainly does matter if you intend to take some action about it. To go to extremes, what would be the different in your actions if:
a) You had to get the house re-decorated before the end of this month?
or
b) You had to get the house redecorated by Jan 2020?
I suggest there would be a radical difference in the actions you would take. Exactly the same applies to a lesser scale to your Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 example.
<< If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date? >>
I think the example you give shows that a goal does need a date, because until you decide that you are going to be in NYC by 9am Saturday you won't take any action towards actually getting there, e.g. book plane tickets, arrange time off work, packing etc. The new time doesn't mean you have failed at your goal - it means you have to take some further actions, e.g. change travel arrangements, re-book housesitter, etc. Without the date you can neither take the first actions nor the subsequent ones.
You want to redecorate your house, but it doesn't matter whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or 2012? Well, it certainly does matter if you intend to take some action about it. To go to extremes, what would be the different in your actions if:
a) You had to get the house re-decorated before the end of this month?
or
b) You had to get the house redecorated by Jan 2020?
I suggest there would be a radical difference in the actions you would take. Exactly the same applies to a lesser scale to your Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 example.
Reply by Jacqueline
I think the difference between the two - Jan 2010 vs 2012 or 2020 - is the "HAD TO" part.
In Lillian's example, there is no "have to", although there is a "want to", so turning 'nice to have' into 'have to have' can be demotivating because she's interested and possibly committed, but it's not necessary.
Same thing goes if she doesn't HAVE to be in NYC, just wants to be.
That's just my take anyway.
In Lillian's example, there is no "have to", although there is a "want to", so turning 'nice to have' into 'have to have' can be demotivating because she's interested and possibly committed, but it's not necessary.
Same thing goes if she doesn't HAVE to be in NYC, just wants to be.
That's just my take anyway.
Reply by Mark Forster
Well, yes... but, if you want to actually succeed in getting to NYC, at some stage you have to say "I'm aiming to be there [on Saturday at 9am]". Otherwise you'll still be thinking "it would be nice to go to NYC" when the Grim Reaper calls.
Reply by Jacqueline
Hopefully not when the Grim Reaper calls if you've put it on your AF list. :-)
But for her redecorating, she doesn't have to put a target date of estimated completion on it if she just works on it continually and it's done when it's done (and sometimes those kinds of goals are never officially *done* anyway). I don't think most people would or should put an estimated completion date on a goal like that unless they were selling the house or having a family reunion at a certain time or other external event.
I could have a goal of $1M net worth by X retirement date but then the market takes a downturn. If it does, I'll likely be upset that I didn't make the date. But if I made a goal of $1M net worth and I don't have a date to pull the plug, I'll just keep on working until I hit the net worth target. Yes, I'd still be upset if the market took a downturn but I haven't beaten myself up for not making the predetermined date. I'd probably have a vague timeframe in mind for when I think I could achieve it based on a savings rate and normal rate of market returns but I'd probably just revise my target net worth down by the amount that I lost and figure out alternative ways to save more so that I could live without having quite $1M. That's the X-15% (or given the 2008 market, X-25%).
Lillian, the author you're thinking of is Bobb Biehl.
But for her redecorating, she doesn't have to put a target date of estimated completion on it if she just works on it continually and it's done when it's done (and sometimes those kinds of goals are never officially *done* anyway). I don't think most people would or should put an estimated completion date on a goal like that unless they were selling the house or having a family reunion at a certain time or other external event.
I could have a goal of $1M net worth by X retirement date but then the market takes a downturn. If it does, I'll likely be upset that I didn't make the date. But if I made a goal of $1M net worth and I don't have a date to pull the plug, I'll just keep on working until I hit the net worth target. Yes, I'd still be upset if the market took a downturn but I haven't beaten myself up for not making the predetermined date. I'd probably have a vague timeframe in mind for when I think I could achieve it based on a savings rate and normal rate of market returns but I'd probably just revise my target net worth down by the amount that I lost and figure out alternative ways to save more so that I could live without having quite $1M. That's the X-15% (or given the 2008 market, X-25%).
Lillian, the author you're thinking of is Bobb Biehl.
Reply by Mike
Lillian,
>>> But since we're here... If I set a goal of "Be in NewYork City this Saturday at 9am" I can spend the week planning the trip, packing, etc etc. Then sometimes comes up on Friday which makes "Saturday at 9am" unlikely. I change the goal to "Be in NewYork City this Sunday at 9am" Goal set. Feedback received. Goal changed.
But the original goal was not achieved. I am not in NYC Satuday. <<<
Calling it "the original goal" implies that you are still thinking of goals as static.
But more than that, I see two other practical problems. Firstly, if you check for feedback on Friday for a goal set for Ssaturday, you are not taking feedback soon enough to affect the outcome. If you set the goal on Monday, you should be checking Monday evening to see what you have accomplished, then Tuesday a couple of times, then Wednesday, etc. Doing that will not leave you revising the goal at the last minute. It will allow you (and this is the second point) to revise your ACTIONS so that you can ACHIEVE the goal you set. IOW, the point is not to move the deadline ever forward, but to alter your actions to achieve the goal. You are seeing "feedback" as altering the goal rather than the actions which will allow the goal to be achieved. When the captain of the ship sees that he is off course (or these days, when his computerized nav system does) he does not abandon his goal of getting to port on time ... he moves his rudder and adjusts the power output of his engines. And he does not wait until he is an hour away from docking to take his position and find he is nearer Greenland than NYC ;-)
>>> If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date? <<<
A goal needs a date, not because the date itself is in any way significant, but to allow us to measure progress. IOW two goals:
1) Make $1M
2) Make $1M by January 2011
The first is not considered a goal because there is no point at which you can measure it and say if you have achieved it or not. If January 2050 comes and goes and I ask you if you made your $1M you can truthfully say: "Not yet but I will." So there is no accountability. No way to say that you are on or off course, thus no way to correct your course ... because you don't know if it needs correction or not.
>>I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating.<<
Exactly - I need to get my head/motivation around this one. Yes, I want to redecorate my house (step 1 - tell dh :) ) but whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 or whatever doesn't really matter. <<<
Try looking at it this way: If you add the date, be it 2010 or 2012 to it, THEN you have a way to measure if you are on track for it. No, it does not matter WHAT the date is, it matters that there is SOME date. You will never tell DH that you want to do that if you never have a time pressure of some kind. If you don't have a date to have it done, then you don't have a date when you need to call the contractor, or consultant, or go to the shops to look at furniture. If you have no time pressure to do those things, you certainly don't need to bother DH about it ;-)
>>> But since we're here... If I set a goal of "Be in NewYork City this Saturday at 9am" I can spend the week planning the trip, packing, etc etc. Then sometimes comes up on Friday which makes "Saturday at 9am" unlikely. I change the goal to "Be in NewYork City this Sunday at 9am" Goal set. Feedback received. Goal changed.
But the original goal was not achieved. I am not in NYC Satuday. <<<
Calling it "the original goal" implies that you are still thinking of goals as static.
But more than that, I see two other practical problems. Firstly, if you check for feedback on Friday for a goal set for Ssaturday, you are not taking feedback soon enough to affect the outcome. If you set the goal on Monday, you should be checking Monday evening to see what you have accomplished, then Tuesday a couple of times, then Wednesday, etc. Doing that will not leave you revising the goal at the last minute. It will allow you (and this is the second point) to revise your ACTIONS so that you can ACHIEVE the goal you set. IOW, the point is not to move the deadline ever forward, but to alter your actions to achieve the goal. You are seeing "feedback" as altering the goal rather than the actions which will allow the goal to be achieved. When the captain of the ship sees that he is off course (or these days, when his computerized nav system does) he does not abandon his goal of getting to port on time ... he moves his rudder and adjusts the power output of his engines. And he does not wait until he is an hour away from docking to take his position and find he is nearer Greenland than NYC ;-)
>>> If the time doesn't matter (and in this case, let's say it really doesn't matter what day I arrive in NYC) why does a date need to be part of a goal? Does a goal really need a date? <<<
A goal needs a date, not because the date itself is in any way significant, but to allow us to measure progress. IOW two goals:
1) Make $1M
2) Make $1M by January 2011
The first is not considered a goal because there is no point at which you can measure it and say if you have achieved it or not. If January 2050 comes and goes and I ask you if you made your $1M you can truthfully say: "Not yet but I will." So there is no accountability. No way to say that you are on or off course, thus no way to correct your course ... because you don't know if it needs correction or not.
>>I think that any time that you have a "deadline" for things that aren't meant to be deadlined, it can be demotivating.<<
Exactly - I need to get my head/motivation around this one. Yes, I want to redecorate my house (step 1 - tell dh :) ) but whether it's finished by Jan 2010 or Jan 2012 or whatever doesn't really matter. <<<
Try looking at it this way: If you add the date, be it 2010 or 2012 to it, THEN you have a way to measure if you are on track for it. No, it does not matter WHAT the date is, it matters that there is SOME date. You will never tell DH that you want to do that if you never have a time pressure of some kind. If you don't have a date to have it done, then you don't have a date when you need to call the contractor, or consultant, or go to the shops to look at furniture. If you have no time pressure to do those things, you certainly don't need to bother DH about it ;-)
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
>>> But for her redecorating, she doesn't have to put a target date of estimated completion on it if she just works on it continually and it's done when it's done <<<
But the argument is that if there is no end point there is no reason to work little and often, lots and seldom, or even at all. Mostly people interested in improving time management skills are interested because they find themselves working not at all, on important goals. "My childhood goal was to be a ballerina, and now I'm 82. Maybe I should think about considering if maybe I might like to plan to schedule some time to start." LOL ;-)
You make a distinction (in another post) between "like to" and "have to". I contend that until "like to" BECOMES "have to" nothing much happens. If you read the biographies of very successful people, they always HAD TO ... no matter what it was. I read a quote by some writer or other (it might have been Azimov) and he said that if he was told he had only one day to live, the only thing he'd change was that he would just type faster. The most successful people say, over and over, that they do what they do because if they could not they would not find life worth living. It is all about HAVE TO.
>>> (and sometimes those kinds of goals are never officially *done* anyway). <<<
That can be true -- but it is also another example of thinking of goals as static. If there is a fixed firm endpoint, and if it is understood that goals are dynamic, then the goal will be altered and what is not "done" is just what was envisioned to start with. The goal will have been modified many times along the way. Maybe the redecoration of the living room included the idea of a home theater. A month into the planning that idea is dropped in favor of library shelves. Have you "failed" in the goal? No, the goal is "changed". Goals are dynamic, not static. If you change the furniture, carpet and drapes, have you failed in the goal because the kitchen is not done?
>>> I don't think most people would or should put an estimated completion date on a goal like that unless they were selling the house or having a family reunion at a certain time or other external event. <<<
I can't speak for "most people" but I assure you that I would. I can also assure you that all clients of decorating consultants and sellers of furniture and drapes will ... because those sellers and consultants want the transaction completed by a certain date or they will not waste their time with you. They are not in business to experience your dreams, but to make money by selling stuff to people who have fixed end dates. They don't get paid until they actually deliver the furniture.
>>> I could have a goal of $1M net worth by X retirement date but then the market takes a downturn. If it does, I'll likely be upset that I didn't make the date. But if I made a goal of $1M net worth and I don't have a date to pull the plug, I'll just keep on working until I hit the net worth target. <<<
Don't you think that the reality is that people without well-formed goals don't work at all on the project? How many people want "to be rich" and never think of what actions that entails?
>>> Yes, I'd still be upset if the market took a downturn but I haven't beaten myself up for not making the predetermined date. <<<
See but "beating yourself up" is not driven by the kind of time management system you use, but how you internalize things and relate to your own self-worth. Those are psychological parameters, not time management ones. Two different people can experience the same market down turn and one be upset and the other see it as an opportunity to get to his goal that much sooner. There is no external objective reality in this ... it is all internal evaluation and response.
>>> I'd probably have a vague timeframe in mind for when I think I could achieve it based on a savings rate and normal rate of market returns but I'd probably just revise my target net worth down by the amount that I lost and figure out alternative ways to save more so that I could live without having quite $1M. That's the X-15% (or given the 2008 market, X-25%). <<<
And that would be an excellent example of a dynamic goal.
>>> But for her redecorating, she doesn't have to put a target date of estimated completion on it if she just works on it continually and it's done when it's done <<<
But the argument is that if there is no end point there is no reason to work little and often, lots and seldom, or even at all. Mostly people interested in improving time management skills are interested because they find themselves working not at all, on important goals. "My childhood goal was to be a ballerina, and now I'm 82. Maybe I should think about considering if maybe I might like to plan to schedule some time to start." LOL ;-)
You make a distinction (in another post) between "like to" and "have to". I contend that until "like to" BECOMES "have to" nothing much happens. If you read the biographies of very successful people, they always HAD TO ... no matter what it was. I read a quote by some writer or other (it might have been Azimov) and he said that if he was told he had only one day to live, the only thing he'd change was that he would just type faster. The most successful people say, over and over, that they do what they do because if they could not they would not find life worth living. It is all about HAVE TO.
>>> (and sometimes those kinds of goals are never officially *done* anyway). <<<
That can be true -- but it is also another example of thinking of goals as static. If there is a fixed firm endpoint, and if it is understood that goals are dynamic, then the goal will be altered and what is not "done" is just what was envisioned to start with. The goal will have been modified many times along the way. Maybe the redecoration of the living room included the idea of a home theater. A month into the planning that idea is dropped in favor of library shelves. Have you "failed" in the goal? No, the goal is "changed". Goals are dynamic, not static. If you change the furniture, carpet and drapes, have you failed in the goal because the kitchen is not done?
>>> I don't think most people would or should put an estimated completion date on a goal like that unless they were selling the house or having a family reunion at a certain time or other external event. <<<
I can't speak for "most people" but I assure you that I would. I can also assure you that all clients of decorating consultants and sellers of furniture and drapes will ... because those sellers and consultants want the transaction completed by a certain date or they will not waste their time with you. They are not in business to experience your dreams, but to make money by selling stuff to people who have fixed end dates. They don't get paid until they actually deliver the furniture.
>>> I could have a goal of $1M net worth by X retirement date but then the market takes a downturn. If it does, I'll likely be upset that I didn't make the date. But if I made a goal of $1M net worth and I don't have a date to pull the plug, I'll just keep on working until I hit the net worth target. <<<
Don't you think that the reality is that people without well-formed goals don't work at all on the project? How many people want "to be rich" and never think of what actions that entails?
>>> Yes, I'd still be upset if the market took a downturn but I haven't beaten myself up for not making the predetermined date. <<<
See but "beating yourself up" is not driven by the kind of time management system you use, but how you internalize things and relate to your own self-worth. Those are psychological parameters, not time management ones. Two different people can experience the same market down turn and one be upset and the other see it as an opportunity to get to his goal that much sooner. There is no external objective reality in this ... it is all internal evaluation and response.
>>> I'd probably have a vague timeframe in mind for when I think I could achieve it based on a savings rate and normal rate of market returns but I'd probably just revise my target net worth down by the amount that I lost and figure out alternative ways to save more so that I could live without having quite $1M. That's the X-15% (or given the 2008 market, X-25%). <<<
And that would be an excellent example of a dynamic goal.
Reply by Jacqueline
Mike, I'm not disagreeing with you - however, I do want to point out one thing that I think is pertinent. It seems that men (in general) are much more goal / outcome oriented and women are more process / performance oriented. Unfortunately most goal oriented literature is written by men, and what works for them may not for women.
There have been studies done on learning in university and the results showed that people received higher grades and experienced greater feelings of efficacy when they had process vs. outcome goals. I'm too lazy to go look up the references, but they're out there.
And I wouldn't turn that goal from a "want to" to a "have to", I would turn it into a WILL do / REALLY REALLY want to do. When I first set my own goal to retire early, I didn't have a date in mind or a certain amount. It was too far out and seemed too nebulous at the time. My outcome time frame was "when I want to do other things more than I want to spend time working." I did have a really good process though. And I just kept sticking to that process day after day and month after month. Yeah, I monitored my progress once in awhile, for maybe 2 minutes once a month but that's it. That's why I'm suggesting that if Lillian or Nicole just ensured that if they kept 5 actions towards their goal on their list at all times or ensuring they spend 5 hours a week on it, or develop certain habits, they'll get there.
Say someone wanted to lose 20 pounds. I think they'd be further ahead by just following a process in their way of eating and exercising and letting the weight take care of itself. Sure, you'd have to do some monitoring to test the effectiveness of your process, but you don't have to tell yourself you HAVE TO lose 2 pounds per week every week to still get there. That's what makes people get unmotivated and quit.
There have been studies done on learning in university and the results showed that people received higher grades and experienced greater feelings of efficacy when they had process vs. outcome goals. I'm too lazy to go look up the references, but they're out there.
And I wouldn't turn that goal from a "want to" to a "have to", I would turn it into a WILL do / REALLY REALLY want to do. When I first set my own goal to retire early, I didn't have a date in mind or a certain amount. It was too far out and seemed too nebulous at the time. My outcome time frame was "when I want to do other things more than I want to spend time working." I did have a really good process though. And I just kept sticking to that process day after day and month after month. Yeah, I monitored my progress once in awhile, for maybe 2 minutes once a month but that's it. That's why I'm suggesting that if Lillian or Nicole just ensured that if they kept 5 actions towards their goal on their list at all times or ensuring they spend 5 hours a week on it, or develop certain habits, they'll get there.
Say someone wanted to lose 20 pounds. I think they'd be further ahead by just following a process in their way of eating and exercising and letting the weight take care of itself. Sure, you'd have to do some monitoring to test the effectiveness of your process, but you don't have to tell yourself you HAVE TO lose 2 pounds per week every week to still get there. That's what makes people get unmotivated and quit.
Reply by Joseph
Mr Forster:
>>Remember it's better to do a few things well than a lot of things badly. >>
Unless, those many things are really, really important things. Then they might be worth doing well OR badly. : )
"if a thing is worth doing, it is worth doing badly" -- G.K. Chesterton, "What's Wrong with the World"
Of course, perhaps there aren't a multiplicity of truly important things. . .
--Joseph
>>Remember it's better to do a few things well than a lot of things badly. >>
Unless, those many things are really, really important things. Then they might be worth doing well OR badly. : )
"if a thing is worth doing, it is worth doing badly" -- G.K. Chesterton, "What's Wrong with the World"
Of course, perhaps there aren't a multiplicity of truly important things. . .
--Joseph
Reply by little b
Hi Joseph,
My husband, frustratingly neat, tidy and efficient, swears by the maxim "better done badly than not done at all".
Very different from my attitude - "do it properly, or not at all".
We have happy times in our house, we do :-)
My husband, frustratingly neat, tidy and efficient, swears by the maxim "better done badly than not done at all".
Very different from my attitude - "do it properly, or not at all".
We have happy times in our house, we do :-)
Reply by Mike
Hi Jacqueline,
>>> Mike, I'm not disagreeing with you - however, <<<
LOL ;-) But that's fine. Lots of people disagree with me.
>>> I do want to point out one thing that I think is pertinent. It seems that men (in general) are much more goal / outcome oriented and women are more process / performance oriented. Unfortunately most goal oriented literature is written by men, and what works for them may not for women. <<<
Ehhhh, mmmmm, I can make an anthropological case for that point of view, and my experience "seems" to support it, but then the counter examples are many. I wonder if Learning would describe herself as "not goal oriented". (Learning, what do you think?)
In my own life, I've had two wives and BOTH are/were very goal oriented ... perhaps more goal oriented than I am. One was a roaring E1 and could not sit still for two minutes without making a list (at least mentally). So while my observation of "soccer moms" comports with this idea, my experience of women in the circles I've lived in does not.
>>> There have been studies done on learning in university and the results showed that people received higher grades and experienced greater feelings of efficacy when they had process vs. outcome goals. I'm too lazy to go look up the references, but they're out there. <<<
Well, there are all kinds of studies posted on the web and I'm not at all sure that even a small percent of them are real. ;-) Yes, if you want good grades it is a good idea to have a good process of study and apply it continually. OTOH, if you don't have a well-formed goal to get that master's thesis written, you'll never get out of school. IMO, what determines a process vs. goal oriented approach is the task itself, not the sex of the person doing it. Things that are more like projects require goals, things that are less, probably benefit from a level of effort approach. Ex. Organizing the garage is more of a project and might benefit from a goal approach ... keeping an organized house clean and organized is a level of effort thing ... vacuum weekly, mop the floors every other week, always put things away, etc.
>>> And I wouldn't turn that goal from a "want to" to a "have to", I would turn it into a WILL do / REALLY REALLY want to do. <<<
I can see that point of view. In fact, I think a WILL DO is a step beyond HAVE TO.
>>> When I first set my own goal to retire early, I didn't have a date in mind or a certain amount. It was too far out and seemed too nebulous at the time. My outcome time frame was "when I want to do other things more than I want to spend time working." I did have a really good process though. And I just kept sticking to that process day after day and month after month. Yeah, I monitored my progress once in awhile, for maybe 2 minutes once a month but that's it. That's why I'm suggesting that if Lillian or Nicole just ensured that if they kept 5 actions towards their goal on their list at all times or ensuring they spend 5 hours a week on it, or develop certain habits, they'll get there. <<<
Yes, but remember that the start of this thread had to do with being discouraged about not getting to goals. Then it became a question of if the goals were the right ones. If you don't have the "right" goals, then suggestions about how to achieve them are kind of beside the point, no? I mean, putting "small and often" tasks on your AF list does not help if you don't really think you want to do the thing in the first place.
Also, I don't disagree at all with your approach ... for you. And I also don't disagree that it works for some things for me ... it is just not that helpful when a real goal is what is needed. Retiring early seems to have been workable for you with your system. I'd suggest that it might have more to do with your own personal orientation. Realize that you are in the financial area so your thinking is probably basically different than many of us. So for you, looking at a financial goal once in six months might be enough because of your basic thinking and orientation. AND, I'd also wonder if you were perhaps not aware of how often you really did take the measure of things ... if only subliminally.
Now I'm not that much interested in the world of finance. So for me I need to plan to get to a goal and take specific steps and have reminders and milestones and all of that ... or it just never gets done. And AF won't do it for me for that. I don't care how many times I see the task on my AF list, I'm going to ignore it ... unless it has the emphasis of a scheduled task because of its importance. Even something like "charge batteries" (which needs to be done monthly and takes only two seconds of work to plug in the charger) gets put off for weeks because I've got other things on my mind. AF works brilliantly for some things and not at all for others ... in my case. Charging the batteries is on my tickler so it gets done ... I respect the urgency of items on the tickler. Accelerating the pay down on my home equity line of credit is automated so it gets done no matter what. In fact, what has made the most difference to me personally has been learning what works and what does not. In my veiw, success is not learning one new tool but having a suite of tools which you know how to apply. (I.E. habits, ticklers, calendar entries, goals, reviews, someday/maybe list, must do tasks, blocked time, and now AF. All of those taken together make up my system. No single one works alone.)
>>> Say someone wanted to lose 20 pounds. I think they'd be further ahead by just following a process in their way of eating and exercising and letting the weight take care of itself. Sure, you'd have to do some monitoring to test the effectiveness of your process, but you don't have to tell yourself you HAVE TO lose 2 pounds per week every week to still get there. That's what makes people get unmotivated and quit. <<<
And there again, I both agree and disagree. If you don't set the goal and take feedback you'll just drift. OTOH, if you don't change lifestyle (a process change) you're just as likely to fail. So I see it as a bit of both. As to HAVE to lose 20 pounds ... I can tell you that I did not start to get my weight under control until I got the results of my physical and had to decide if chocolate cake was preferable to living a few more years. That is a HAVE TO. situation. And once I got to that mental place, the "process" became easier to stick with ... and it is the PROCESS that is doing the heavy lifting. I also found that in the beginning I needed feedback to learn the process and later I found feedback motivational. It sure is much easier to turn your back on the cake after seeing the number on the scale drop in the morning. Who wants to undo that success? Personally, I found that if the number went UP for some reason, it was motivation to take a harder look at what I did yesterday ... it was not depressing. But then, YMMV, of course ;-)
>>> Mike, I'm not disagreeing with you - however, <<<
LOL ;-) But that's fine. Lots of people disagree with me.
>>> I do want to point out one thing that I think is pertinent. It seems that men (in general) are much more goal / outcome oriented and women are more process / performance oriented. Unfortunately most goal oriented literature is written by men, and what works for them may not for women. <<<
Ehhhh, mmmmm,
In my own life, I've had two wives and BOTH are/were very goal oriented ... perhaps more goal oriented than I am. One was a roaring E1 and could not sit still for two minutes without making a list (at least mentally). So while my observation of "soccer moms" comports with this idea, my experience of women in the circles I've lived in does not.
>>> There have been studies done on learning in university and the results showed that people received higher grades and experienced greater feelings of efficacy when they had process vs. outcome goals. I'm too lazy to go look up the references, but they're out there. <<<
Well, there are all kinds of studies posted on the web and I'm not at all sure that even a small percent of them are real. ;-) Yes, if you want good grades it is a good idea to have a good process of study and apply it continually. OTOH, if you don't have a well-formed goal to get that master's thesis written, you'll never get out of school. IMO, what determines a process vs. goal oriented approach is the task itself, not the sex of the person doing it. Things that are more like projects require goals, things that are less, probably benefit from a level of effort approach. Ex. Organizing the garage is more of a project and might benefit from a goal approach ... keeping an organized house clean and organized is a level of effort thing ... vacuum weekly, mop the floors every other week, always put things away, etc.
>>> And I wouldn't turn that goal from a "want to" to a "have to", I would turn it into a WILL do / REALLY REALLY want to do. <<<
I can see that point of view. In fact, I think a WILL DO is a step beyond HAVE TO.
>>> When I first set my own goal to retire early, I didn't have a date in mind or a certain amount. It was too far out and seemed too nebulous at the time. My outcome time frame was "when I want to do other things more than I want to spend time working." I did have a really good process though. And I just kept sticking to that process day after day and month after month. Yeah, I monitored my progress once in awhile, for maybe 2 minutes once a month but that's it. That's why I'm suggesting that if Lillian or Nicole just ensured that if they kept 5 actions towards their goal on their list at all times or ensuring they spend 5 hours a week on it, or develop certain habits, they'll get there. <<<
Yes, but remember that the start of this thread had to do with being discouraged about not getting to goals. Then it became a question of if the goals were the right ones. If you don't have the "right" goals, then suggestions about how to achieve them are kind of beside the point, no? I mean, putting "small and often" tasks on your AF list does not help if you don't really think you want to do the thing in the first place.
Also, I don't disagree at all with your approach ... for you. And I also don't disagree that it works for some things for me ... it is just not that helpful when a real goal is what is needed. Retiring early seems to have been workable for you with your system. I'd suggest that it might have more to do with your own personal orientation. Realize that you are in the financial area so your thinking is probably basically different than many of us. So for you, looking at a financial goal once in six months might be enough because of your basic thinking and orientation. AND, I'd also wonder if you were perhaps not aware of how often you really did take the measure of things ... if only subliminally.
Now I'm not that much interested in the world of finance. So for me I need to plan to get to a goal and take specific steps and have reminders and milestones and all of that ... or it just never gets done. And AF won't do it for me for that. I don't care how many times I see the task on my AF list, I'm going to ignore it ... unless it has the emphasis of a scheduled task because of its importance. Even something like "charge batteries" (which needs to be done monthly and takes only two seconds of work to plug in the charger) gets put off for weeks because I've got other things on my mind. AF works brilliantly for some things and not at all for others ... in my case. Charging the batteries is on my tickler so it gets done ... I respect the urgency of items on the tickler. Accelerating the pay down on my home equity line of credit is automated so it gets done no matter what. In fact, what has made the most difference to me personally has been learning what works and what does not. In my veiw, success is not learning one new tool but having a suite of tools which you know how to apply. (I.E. habits, ticklers, calendar entries, goals, reviews, someday/maybe list, must do tasks, blocked time, and now AF. All of those taken together make up my system. No single one works alone.)
>>> Say someone wanted to lose 20 pounds. I think they'd be further ahead by just following a process in their way of eating and exercising and letting the weight take care of itself. Sure, you'd have to do some monitoring to test the effectiveness of your process, but you don't have to tell yourself you HAVE TO lose 2 pounds per week every week to still get there. That's what makes people get unmotivated and quit. <<<
And there again, I both agree and disagree. If you don't set the goal and take feedback you'll just drift. OTOH, if you don't change lifestyle (a process change) you're just as likely to fail. So I see it as a bit of both. As to HAVE to lose 20 pounds ... I can tell you that I did not start to get my weight under control until I got the results of my physical and had to decide if chocolate cake was preferable to living a few more years. That is a HAVE TO. situation. And once I got to that mental place, the "process" became easier to stick with ... and it is the PROCESS that is doing the heavy lifting. I also found that in the beginning I needed feedback to learn the process and later I found feedback motivational. It sure is much easier to turn your back on the cake after seeing the number on the scale drop in the morning. Who wants to undo that success? Personally, I found that if the number went UP for some reason, it was motivation to take a harder look at what I did yesterday ... it was not depressing. But then, YMMV, of course ;-)
Reply by learning as I go
Hi Mike
I don't have time to read your post in full yet, but my ego noticed my name......
GUILTY as charged................I'm one of the WORST sinners in goal addiction! Yet, achieving my goals has always been the driving force and highlights of my experiencing life because the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself. I'm sure it's an admixture of early indoctrination and genetics so I won't feel guilty or inappropriately too manish. LOL! I embrace my femininity while loving to push my limits. When I push hard I need to see in my mind what I'm striving for. The pure process is reverie and it can also be horribly punishing at times. Excellence or any growth always has components of both. That's my take on it.
I'll read the rest of your article later. Break over...
vickie
I don't have time to read your post in full yet, but my ego noticed my name......
GUILTY as charged................I'm one of the WORST sinners in goal addiction! Yet, achieving my goals has always been the driving force and highlights of my experiencing life because the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself. I'm sure it's an admixture of early indoctrination and genetics so I won't feel guilty or inappropriately too manish. LOL! I embrace my femininity while loving to push my limits. When I push hard I need to see in my mind what I'm striving for. The pure process is reverie and it can also be horribly punishing at times. Excellence or any growth always has components of both. That's my take on it.
I'll read the rest of your article later. Break over...
vickie
Reply by Jacqueline
Mike, it seems that with your very approach to AF, you are much more outcome oriented than process oriented than most. Back in the day when I toyed with the thought of competing in BB, this article was helpful to me in understanding the difference:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/goal-versus-process-oriented-training-part-1.html
The process oriented person would work with the AF system, following the steps and could end up with a backlog (like Nicole, Christine and others - even me) or unmanageable list, then tweak their process. But those people will usually strive *very* hard (maybe too hard) to stick rigidly to the process rather than listen to what the measurement is telling them because that's the way they're oriented. The outcome oriented person would tweak their process much sooner based on feedback. But the process person is usually focused on the process itself as their indicator of how they're doing. It seems they will also be more interested in keeping stats on how the process is working rather than how they're progressing towards their goals/outcomes. So the process is more critical to them than the goals themselves. Even more reason to develop an iron-clad process.
It's all very interesting, but I still maintain that if measuring in time doesn't work for someone then find what does. You step on the scale and see your weight went up and feel motivated. I do the same thing and get frustrated and want to give up - or re-focus on the process. Organizations like Weight Watchers are built around a process towards a goal (which is not timed, it is completely process oriented).
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/goal-versus-process-oriented-training-part-1.html
The process oriented person would work with the AF system, following the steps and could end up with a backlog (like Nicole, Christine and others - even me) or unmanageable list, then tweak their process. But those people will usually strive *very* hard (maybe too hard) to stick rigidly to the process rather than listen to what the measurement is telling them because that's the way they're oriented. The outcome oriented person would tweak their process much sooner based on feedback. But the process person is usually focused on the process itself as their indicator of how they're doing. It seems they will also be more interested in keeping stats on how the process is working rather than how they're progressing towards their goals/outcomes. So the process is more critical to them than the goals themselves. Even more reason to develop an iron-clad process.
It's all very interesting, but I still maintain that if measuring in time doesn't work for someone then find what does. You step on the scale and see your weight went up and feel motivated. I do the same thing and get frustrated and want to give up - or re-focus on the process. Organizations like Weight Watchers are built around a process towards a goal (which is not timed, it is completely process oriented).
Reply by Jacqueline
Well FWIW Mike, in her response learning confirmed my theory that she's focused on the process, not the outcome - ie. winning. It doesn't mean she doesn't have GOALS, I mean I have goals too, I'm just concerned with the process more than the outcome.
"the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself."
I shouldn't have said "goal/outcome orientation" when I meant more outcome orientation, because being process oriented doesn't mean that you don't have goals. Obviously someone like Nicole or Lillian has a goal, IIRC, I even told Norman that he has a goal, it just might not be a very good one.
Maybe it's not just women, but even anecdotally on this board I think the theory holds. Or so my E5 personality has observed.
But I'll let you win this discussion since you're an E5W6, cuz I've had my fun in the process of discussing it. ;-)
"the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself."
I shouldn't have said "goal/outcome orientation" when I meant more outcome orientation, because being process oriented doesn't mean that you don't have goals. Obviously someone like Nicole or Lillian has a goal, IIRC, I even told Norman that he has a goal, it just might not be a very good one.
Maybe it's not just women, but even anecdotally on this board I think the theory holds. Or so my E5 personality has observed.
But I'll let you win this discussion since you're an E5W6, cuz I've had my fun in the process of discussing it. ;-)
Reply by learning as I go
(((Jacq and Mike)))
I love you guys! Your discussions keep my mind well-nourished and entertained! You discussions are both the meat and the desert!
learning as I go
I love you guys! Your discussions keep my mind well-nourished and entertained! You discussions are both the meat and the desert!
learning as I go
Reply by Damien
Jacqueline:
Robert Boice fails to mention the gender aspect when studying process-product styles. But then maybe seeing, a gender distinction in styles, is also gender dependent :)
Just a quote to illustrate the two process-product styles:
"...they (procrastinators) are also relatively unique in maintaining a product (as distinct from process) orientation where they concentrate more on the outcomes they believe they need (for example, ‘‘I’ll need to finish twenty-five pages of good prose this weekend’’) than on ways of learning to work more efficiently and durably (‘‘Maybe I would get more done in the long run if I stopped planning such big goals and just settled into doing a few good pages a day’’ [see Dweck, 1986 for other examples of process versus product styles of problem solving])." Robert Boice
Robert Boice fails to mention the gender aspect when studying process-product styles. But then maybe seeing, a gender distinction in styles, is also gender dependent :)
Just a quote to illustrate the two process-product styles:
"...they (procrastinators) are also relatively unique in maintaining a product (as distinct from process) orientation where they concentrate more on the outcomes they believe they need (for example, ‘‘I’ll need to finish twenty-five pages of good prose this weekend’’) than on ways of learning to work more efficiently and durably (‘‘Maybe I would get more done in the long run if I stopped planning such big goals and just settled into doing a few good pages a day’’ [see Dweck, 1986 for other examples of process versus product styles of problem solving])." Robert Boice
Reply by Jacqueline
Damien,
Is the "Dweck" you're referring to Carol Dweck who wrote "Mindset"? (I enjoyed the book).
This one?
https://www.stanford.edu/dept/psychology/cgi-bin/drupalm/cdweck
https://www.stanford.edu/dept/psychology/cgi-bin/drupalm/system/files/A%20social-cognitive%20approach_0.pdf
Is the "Dweck" you're referring to Carol Dweck who wrote "Mindset"? (I enjoyed the book).
This one?
https://www.stanford.edu/dept/psychology/cgi-bin/drupalm/cdweck
https://www.stanford.edu/dept/psychology/cgi-bin/drupalm/system/files/A%20social-cognitive%20approach_0.pdf
Reply by Damien
Yes it is the same Dweck. The article Robert Boice refers to "Dweck, C. (1986). Motivational processes affecting learning. American Psychologist, 41, 1040–1048" is also mentioned in her CV (not in pubmed).
Reply by Mike
Hey Jacqueline,
>>> Mike, it seems that with your very approach to AF, you are much more outcome oriented than process oriented than most. Back in the day when I toyed with the thought of competing in BB, this article was helpful to me in understanding the difference:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/goal-versus-process-oriented-training-part-1.html >>>
The problem I have with the article is that it confuses outcome (and the method of its achievement ... or lack thereof) with ones reaction to outcome. It is NOT true that missing a goal MUST cause a person to auger in. That extreme and self-destructive reaction to the event is a problem, but it does not flow necessarily from the kind of management system one uses. Put another way, if the thesis is that goal oriented persons are psychologically unstable because of that orientation ... it is an argument that must be made explicitly ... not simply asserted.
>>> The process oriented person would work with the AF system, following the steps and could end up with a backlog (like Nicole, Christine and others - even me) or unmanageable list, then tweak their process. But those people will usually strive *very* hard (maybe too hard) to stick rigidly to the process rather than listen to what the measurement is telling them because that's the way they're oriented. The outcome oriented person would tweak their process much sooner based on feedback. But the process person is usually focused on the process itself as their indicator of how they're doing. It seems they will also be more interested in keeping stats on how the process is working rather than how they're progressing towards their goals/outcomes. So the process is more critical to them than the goals themselves. Even more reason to develop an iron-clad process. <<<
That sounds about right to me.
>>> It's all very interesting, but I still maintain that if measuring in time doesn't work for someone then find what does. <<<
Of course.
>>> You step on the scale and see your weight went up and feel motivated. I do the same thing and get frustrated and want to give up - or re-focus on the process. Organizations like Weight Watchers are built around a process towards a goal (which is not timed, it is completely process oriented). <<<
Well, whatever works. I don't think, however, that the way you react to a situation is carved in stone. Sometimes it makes more sense to change the way you react. Changing that might have longer term and more wide reaching benefits. Just a thought.
>>> Well FWIW Mike, in her response learning confirmed my theory that she's focused on the process, not the outcome - ie. winning. It doesn't mean she doesn't have GOALS, I mean I have goals too, I'm just concerned with the process more than the outcome. <<<
Good gosh, we are so different in our perspectives. I read her response to mean that she is VERY goal oriented. Yes, she revels in her work, but she is driven by the goal and measures her course by that goal. What she is NOT, is emotionally enslaved by missing the goal.
>>> "the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself." <<<
What I read there is that she is not measuring by external EVALUATION of her work. I make a distinction between internal vs. external evaluation and the method one uses to achieve ones aims (goal vs. process).
>>> I shouldn't have said "goal/outcome orientation" when I meant more outcome orientation, because being process oriented doesn't mean that you don't have goals. Obviously someone like Nicole or Lillian has a goal, IIRC, I even told Norman that he has a goal, it just might not be a very good one. <<<
I think there are a lot of confusing terms, to be sure. It is possible to have a goal, but not be goal "oriented" in how one works. IOW, I want to make $1M but I don't plan my steps and check my progress. It is also possible to have "dreams" which one thinks are goals.
>>> Maybe it's not just women, but even anecdotally on this board I think the theory holds. Or so my E5 personality has observed. <<<
ROTF ;-)
>>> But I'll let you win this discussion since you're an E5W6, cuz I've had my fun in the process of discussing it. ;-) <<<
It's all good. It is mostly a matter of perspective.
>>> Mike, it seems that with your very approach to AF, you are much more outcome oriented than process oriented than most. Back in the day when I toyed with the thought of competing in BB, this article was helpful to me in understanding the difference:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/goal-versus-process-oriented-training-part-1.html >>>
The problem I have with the article is that it confuses outcome (and the method of its achievement ... or lack thereof) with ones reaction to outcome. It is NOT true that missing a goal MUST cause a person to auger in. That extreme and self-destructive reaction to the event is a problem, but it does not flow necessarily from the kind of management system one uses. Put another way, if the thesis is that goal oriented persons are psychologically unstable because of that orientation ... it is an argument that must be made explicitly ... not simply asserted.
>>> The process oriented person would work with the AF system, following the steps and could end up with a backlog (like Nicole, Christine and others - even me) or unmanageable list, then tweak their process. But those people will usually strive *very* hard (maybe too hard) to stick rigidly to the process rather than listen to what the measurement is telling them because that's the way they're oriented. The outcome oriented person would tweak their process much sooner based on feedback. But the process person is usually focused on the process itself as their indicator of how they're doing. It seems they will also be more interested in keeping stats on how the process is working rather than how they're progressing towards their goals/outcomes. So the process is more critical to them than the goals themselves. Even more reason to develop an iron-clad process. <<<
That sounds about right to me.
>>> It's all very interesting, but I still maintain that if measuring in time doesn't work for someone then find what does. <<<
Of course.
>>> You step on the scale and see your weight went up and feel motivated. I do the same thing and get frustrated and want to give up - or re-focus on the process. Organizations like Weight Watchers are built around a process towards a goal (which is not timed, it is completely process oriented). <<<
Well, whatever works. I don't think, however, that the way you react to a situation is carved in stone. Sometimes it makes more sense to change the way you react. Changing that might have longer term and more wide reaching benefits. Just a thought.
>>> Well FWIW Mike, in her response learning confirmed my theory that she's focused on the process, not the outcome - ie. winning. It doesn't mean she doesn't have GOALS, I mean I have goals too, I'm just concerned with the process more than the outcome. <<<
Good gosh, we are so different in our perspectives. I read her response to mean that she is VERY goal oriented. Yes, she revels in her work, but she is driven by the goal and measures her course by that goal. What she is NOT, is emotionally enslaved by missing the goal.
>>> "the competition is mostly with stretching myself. The trophy or blue ribbon was only superfluous decoration. I've even not placed well in some competitions where I actually felt great about myself." <<<
What I read there is that she is not measuring by external EVALUATION of her work. I make a distinction between internal vs. external evaluation and the method one uses to achieve ones aims (goal vs. process).
>>> I shouldn't have said "goal/outcome orientation" when I meant more outcome orientation, because being process oriented doesn't mean that you don't have goals. Obviously someone like Nicole or Lillian has a goal, IIRC, I even told Norman that he has a goal, it just might not be a very good one. <<<
I think there are a lot of confusing terms, to be sure. It is possible to have a goal, but not be goal "oriented" in how one works. IOW, I want to make $1M but I don't plan my steps and check my progress. It is also possible to have "dreams" which one thinks are goals.
>>> Maybe it's not just women, but even anecdotally on this board I think the theory holds. Or so my E5 personality has observed. <<<
ROTF ;-)
>>> But I'll let you win this discussion since you're an E5W6, cuz I've had my fun in the process of discussing it. ;-) <<<
It's all good. It is mostly a matter of perspective.
Reply by Mark T.
What are the other questions Alan Lakein recommends for uncovering your "true goals"?
Reply by Mike
Mark,
That was the best of my recollection. I'm sorry to say that I'm not prepared to dig out the book and type it in here right now ;-) It is actually a pretty cheap paperback and can be found on Amazon, as well as most used book stores. Honestly, it is well worth reading.
That was the best of my recollection. I'm sorry to say that I'm not prepared to dig out the book and type it in here right now ;-) It is actually a pretty cheap paperback and can be found on Amazon, as well as most used book stores. Honestly, it is well worth reading.
Reply by Jacqueline
Mark T,
Here's the process from Lakein's book.
Write at the top of a piece of paper the question #1:
"What are my lifetime goals?"
Take 2 minutes to list answers on your paper, take into account personal, family, social, career, financial, community and spiritual goals.
Question #2:
"How would I like to spend the next three years?" (if you're over 30, make it 5 years)
Question #3:
"If I knew now I would be struck dead by lightning six months from today, how would I live until then?"
Like Mike says, best to read the book to put it in context, plus it has excellent advice on time management in general, specifically prioritization. Otherwise it's possible to write up goals but never achieve them.
Here's the process from Lakein's book.
Write at the top of a piece of paper the question #1:
"What are my lifetime goals?"
Take 2 minutes to list answers on your paper, take into account personal, family, social, career, financial, community and spiritual goals.
Question #2:
"How would I like to spend the next three years?" (if you're over 30, make it 5 years)
Question #3:
"If I knew now I would be struck dead by lightning six months from today, how would I live until then?"
Like Mike says, best to read the book to put it in context, plus it has excellent advice on time management in general, specifically prioritization. Otherwise it's possible to write up goals but never achieve them.
Reply by Mark T.
Thanks Jacqueline.
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
Yes, the questions alone don't explain enough.
Also, IIRC, there are something like 101 techniques for dealing with procrastination among which there must be at least ONE good idea for everyone.
Yes, the questions alone don't explain enough.
Also, IIRC, there are something like 101 techniques for dealing with procrastination among which there must be at least ONE good idea for everyone.
Reply by Jacqueline
Hi Mike,
If you're thinking of the appendix - which is the only place with a list of techniques - that's entitled "How I Save Time." There's 61 techniques on that, all of which are good. I have always really liked his perspective on what he defines as "A" projects/activities - it's not always work, work, work. It's pretty much the bible of time management IMHO and should be required reading in high school.
If you're thinking of the appendix - which is the only place with a list of techniques - that's entitled "How I Save Time." There's 61 techniques on that, all of which are good. I have always really liked his perspective on what he defines as "A" projects/activities - it's not always work, work, work. It's pretty much the bible of time management IMHO and should be required reading in high school.
Reply by Mike
Hi Jacqueline,
Yes, that is exactly what I was thinking of. I've not read the book in a few years so the details became a bit fuzzy ;-)
Taught in High School: Egad, what a concept. I've always maintained that what should be taught in the early years are not myths about friendly Indians giving corn to impeccably dressed Puritans on Thanksgiving ... but rather the crucial tools to manage one's self in the coming years. But hey, that's just me and my ADD talking here ;-)
Yes, that is exactly what I was thinking of. I've not read the book in a few years so the details became a bit fuzzy ;-)
Taught in High School: Egad, what a concept. I've always maintained that what should be taught in the early years are not myths about friendly Indians giving corn to impeccably dressed Puritans on Thanksgiving ... but rather the crucial tools to manage one's self in the coming years. But hey, that's just me and my ADD talking here ;-)
Reply by Mark Forster
"If I knew now I would be struck dead by lightning six months from today, how would I live until then?"
I'd sell my house and all my investments and see if I could spend the lot.
But what happens then if the expected lightning strike doesn't happen?
I'd sell my house and all my investments and see if I could spend the lot.
But what happens then if the expected lightning strike doesn't happen?
Reply by Jacqueline
Mark,
You mean you wouldn't give time management seminars or delete spam about Russian women if you only had 6 months to go?!!? ;-)
I think that's most people's first reactions but you get good goals out of it once you've gotten past the trivial answers like that. Oddly enough, I'd try not to spend a thing because I'd want my kids to be secure and buying junk or traveling first class doesn't make me that happy. I think most people that do encounter that circumstance in real life don't madly spend everything. I'd probably spend a lot of time with my friends and family, travel a bit, ski or hike a lot, write a book, build a lake cabin for/with my kids and maybe push Mike to climb Mount Everest with me.
Come to think of it, there was a writer - can't recall the name - maybe 19th century? - who had some kind of fatal prognosis and ended up leaving his job and writing tons of books because he wanted to provide for his family. I think he actually ended up living longer though.
Randy Pausch chose to run around giving lectures in pretty much exactly that circumstance. I've heard that he had a pretty big ego and was a major workaholic, so there's different strokes I guess.
You mean you wouldn't give time management seminars or delete spam about Russian women if you only had 6 months to go?!!? ;-)
I think that's most people's first reactions but you get good goals out of it once you've gotten past the trivial answers like that. Oddly enough, I'd try not to spend a thing because I'd want my kids to be secure and buying junk or traveling first class doesn't make me that happy. I think most people that do encounter that circumstance in real life don't madly spend everything. I'd probably spend a lot of time with my friends and family, travel a bit, ski or hike a lot, write a book, build a lake cabin for/with my kids and maybe push Mike to climb Mount Everest with me.
Come to think of it, there was a writer - can't recall the name - maybe 19th century? - who had some kind of fatal prognosis and ended up leaving his job and writing tons of books because he wanted to provide for his family. I think he actually ended up living longer though.
Randy Pausch chose to run around giving lectures in pretty much exactly that circumstance. I've heard that he had a pretty big ego and was a major workaholic, so there's different strokes I guess.
Reply by little b
jacqueline,
a patient of my dad's went through exactly what you described - he was diagnosed with cancer of the pancreas, which has a very poor prognosis. he was offered various treatments to extend his lifespan, but declined.
instead, he decided to spend the time and money he had left on a "grown up gap year".
whilst he was in india, he went to get a prescription for painkillers, and the doctor who attended him said, "you don't have cancer, you have tuberculosis."
various tests followed, and it transpired he did indeed have TB, not cancer. treatment? antibiotics.
doctors in the UK (not just my dad i hasten to add!) had repeatedly misdiagnosed him because it's such a rare form of TB; in india, TB is much more common and therefore doctors are much better at diagnosing it.
the patient was so thrilled to have his death sentence lifted that he didn't sue, so my dad and his colleagues had an equally lucky escape.
a patient of my dad's went through exactly what you described - he was diagnosed with cancer of the pancreas, which has a very poor prognosis. he was offered various treatments to extend his lifespan, but declined.
instead, he decided to spend the time and money he had left on a "grown up gap year".
whilst he was in india, he went to get a prescription for painkillers, and the doctor who attended him said, "you don't have cancer, you have tuberculosis."
various tests followed, and it transpired he did indeed have TB, not cancer. treatment? antibiotics.
doctors in the UK (not just my dad i hasten to add!) had repeatedly misdiagnosed him because it's such a rare form of TB; in india, TB is much more common and therefore doctors are much better at diagnosing it.
the patient was so thrilled to have his death sentence lifted that he didn't sue, so my dad and his colleagues had an equally lucky escape.
Reply by Mike
Mark,
Put another way (not original with me but I forget my source):
"The problem with the philosophy of 'Eat, Drink, and be Merry for Tomorrow you may die.' is that tomorrow you usually don't."
Put another way (not original with me but I forget my source):
"The problem with the philosophy of 'Eat, Drink, and be Merry for Tomorrow you may die.' is that tomorrow you usually don't."
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
>>> You mean you wouldn't give time management seminars or delete spam about Russian women if you only had 6 months to go?!!? ;-) <<<
LOL ;-)
>>> I think that's most people's first reactions but you get good goals out of it once you've gotten past the trivial answers like that. <<<
And your answer may depend a lot on your current goals, ironically enough. I love that Asimov (I think) quote I just recently stumbled across: "If I knew I were going to die tomorrow, I'd type faster." As Lakein points out, if you are well aligned with your goals you would probably change very little.
>>> Oddly enough, I'd try not to spend a thing because I'd want my kids to be secure and buying junk or traveling first class doesn't make me that happy. I think most people that do encounter that circumstance in real life don't madly spend everything. I'd probably spend a lot of time with my friends and family, travel a bit, ski or hike a lot, write a book, build a lake cabin for/with my kids and maybe push Mike to climb Mount Everest with me. <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I don't know why I got interested in climbing. I used to do some technical rock climbing ... many long years ago. Now, when I see those folks freeing their asses off losing body parts just for the view, I keep thinking I'd rather save up for a ticket on Branson's space shuttle ;-)
>>> Come to think of it, there was a writer - can't recall the name - maybe 19th century? - who had some kind of fatal prognosis and ended up leaving his job and writing tons of books because he wanted to provide for his family. I think he actually ended up living longer though. <<<
That actually happens quite frequently, so I've heard.
>>> Randy Pausch chose to run around giving lectures in pretty much exactly that circumstance. I've heard that he had a pretty big ego and was a major workaholic, so there's different strokes I guess. <<<
While I was impressed with his ability to manage his situation, I thought he would be a royal pain to work with.
>>> You mean you wouldn't give time management seminars or delete spam about Russian women if you only had 6 months to go?!!? ;-) <<<
LOL ;-)
>>> I think that's most people's first reactions but you get good goals out of it once you've gotten past the trivial answers like that. <<<
And your answer may depend a lot on your current goals, ironically enough. I love that Asimov (I think) quote I just recently stumbled across: "If I knew I were going to die tomorrow, I'd type faster." As Lakein points out, if you are well aligned with your goals you would probably change very little.
>>> Oddly enough, I'd try not to spend a thing because I'd want my kids to be secure and buying junk or traveling first class doesn't make me that happy. I think most people that do encounter that circumstance in real life don't madly spend everything. I'd probably spend a lot of time with my friends and family, travel a bit, ski or hike a lot, write a book, build a lake cabin for/with my kids and maybe push Mike to climb Mount Everest with me. <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I don't know why I got interested in climbing. I used to do some technical rock climbing ... many long years ago. Now, when I see those folks freeing their asses off losing body parts just for the view, I keep thinking I'd rather save up for a ticket on Branson's space shuttle ;-)
>>> Come to think of it, there was a writer - can't recall the name - maybe 19th century? - who had some kind of fatal prognosis and ended up leaving his job and writing tons of books because he wanted to provide for his family. I think he actually ended up living longer though. <<<
That actually happens quite frequently, so I've heard.
>>> Randy Pausch chose to run around giving lectures in pretty much exactly that circumstance. I've heard that he had a pretty big ego and was a major workaholic, so there's different strokes I guess. <<<
While I was impressed with his ability to manage his situation, I thought he would be a royal pain to work with.
Reply by Jacqueline
Hey little b and Mike,
It's awesome that this guy had a good resolution. It's kind of sad that anyone would even consider suing because of it though.
I don't know, I'm torn about the 6 months thing etc. I'm seeing a lot of people online nowadays that are all about "lifestyle design" (woo-woo), breaking free of the cubicle, blah blah blah. There seems to be a major emphasis on living NOW without thinking about the future in a very balanced way. While I admire their enthusiasm (and naivety), I question the practicality. But then I don't aspire to eating cat food in 30 years. Maybe that's a sign of getting older. :-) At times it seems like a mass cluster**** where everyone links to and breeds on each other and there's no critical discourse. That's one thing I like about this forum is that it's open to opposing viewpoints in a civilized way.
Here's a neat blog that is quite awesome: :-)
http://beyondgrowth.net/conscious-marketing/overdosing-on-awesome/
And another of my faves:
http://shambook.blogspot.com/2009/10/notes-on-price-of-pursuing-ridiculous.html
It's awesome that this guy had a good resolution. It's kind of sad that anyone would even consider suing because of it though.
I don't know, I'm torn about the 6 months thing etc. I'm seeing a lot of people online nowadays that are all about "lifestyle design" (woo-woo), breaking free of the cubicle, blah blah blah. There seems to be a major emphasis on living NOW without thinking about the future in a very balanced way. While I admire their enthusiasm (and naivety), I question the practicality. But then I don't aspire to eating cat food in 30 years. Maybe that's a sign of getting older. :-) At times it seems like a mass cluster**** where everyone links to and breeds on each other and there's no critical discourse. That's one thing I like about this forum is that it's open to opposing viewpoints in a civilized way.
Here's a neat blog that is quite awesome: :-)
http://beyondgrowth.net/conscious-marketing/overdosing-on-awesome/
And another of my faves:
http://shambook.blogspot.com/2009/10/notes-on-price-of-pursuing-ridiculous.html
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
>>> I don't know, I'm torn about the 6 months thing etc. I'm seeing a lot of people online nowadays that are all about "lifestyle design" (woo-woo), breaking free of the cubicle, blah blah blah. <<<
ROTF ;-) I know what you mean. Drives me crackers at times.
>>> There seems to be a major emphasis on living NOW without thinking about the future in a very balanced way. <<<
Yeah, that is the state of things now ... well, now and for the last few decades and possibly getting worse over time.
>>> While I admire their enthusiasm (and naivety), I question the practicality. But then I don't aspire to eating cat food in 30 years. Maybe that's a sign of getting older. :-) <<<
LOL ;-)
>>> At times it seems like a mass cluster**** where everyone links to and breeds on each other and there's no critical discourse. That's one thing I like about this forum is that it's open to opposing viewpoints in a civilized way. <<<
Yes, I do too. The thing about that goal setting question is that it acts as a check on blue sky thinking such as you might object to. After you have decided that you want to climb Mt. Everst as a long term goal and you confront the question of what you would do if you only had a few months left, you realize that you would not care to go mountain climbing after all. I think it is a good way to put some reality into planning.
Nice blogs. I like that perspective.
>>> I don't know, I'm torn about the 6 months thing etc. I'm seeing a lot of people online nowadays that are all about "lifestyle design" (woo-woo), breaking free of the cubicle, blah blah blah. <<<
ROTF ;-) I know what you mean. Drives me crackers at times.
>>> There seems to be a major emphasis on living NOW without thinking about the future in a very balanced way. <<<
Yeah, that is the state of things now ... well, now and for the last few decades and possibly getting worse over time.
>>> While I admire their enthusiasm (and naivety), I question the practicality. But then I don't aspire to eating cat food in 30 years. Maybe that's a sign of getting older. :-) <<<
LOL ;-)
>>> At times it seems like a mass cluster**** where everyone links to and breeds on each other and there's no critical discourse. That's one thing I like about this forum is that it's open to opposing viewpoints in a civilized way. <<<
Yes, I do too. The thing about that goal setting question is that it acts as a check on blue sky thinking such as you might object to. After you have decided that you want to climb Mt. Everst as a long term goal and you confront the question of what you would do if you only had a few months left, you realize that you would not care to go mountain climbing after all. I think it is a good way to put some reality into planning.
Nice blogs. I like that perspective.
Reply by Jacqueline
Mike, I blame Oprah. I really do. :-)
I wonder how many people dream of doing things like climbing Everest because they love mountain climbing or they just want to be able to say they climbed the big one? I've been wondering lately if some of my goals are like that where I love the idea of doing this grand thing (and they sound impressive too!) more than the process of what it takes to get there. Like I enjoy hiking and often think of doing a thru-hike on the Appalachian or Pacific Coast trail - but would I really enjoy being out there for SIX months?!? Are they just "ego goals"?
I wonder how many people dream of doing things like climbing Everest because they love mountain climbing or they just want to be able to say they climbed the big one? I've been wondering lately if some of my goals are like that where I love the idea of doing this grand thing (and they sound impressive too!) more than the process of what it takes to get there. Like I enjoy hiking and often think of doing a thru-hike on the Appalachian or Pacific Coast trail - but would I really enjoy being out there for SIX months?!? Are they just "ego goals"?
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
I have so much to say about that but I'm shutting down the computer to head off to my in-laws. I'll probably get to this when I have some time in the hotel tomorrow, while my beautiful wife is in her conducting workshop.
'till then ;-)
I have so much to say about that but I'm shutting down the computer to head off to my in-laws. I'll probably get to this when I have some time in the hotel tomorrow, while my beautiful wife is in her conducting workshop.
'till then ;-)
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
Well, it has been unusually hard to get to the internet recently. The silly hotel wanted to charge for internet access. It seems that the Sheraton is living in its own little world. Hell, most McDonald's now have a wi-fi service. Now at my brother-in-law's I find that Comcast is screwing up and needs to replace the drop to the house. But at least there is SOME access ;-(
>>> I wonder how many people dream of doing things like climbing Everest because they love mountain climbing or they just want to be able to say they climbed the big one? I've been wondering lately if some of my goals are like that where I love the idea of doing this grand thing (and they sound impressive too!) more than the process of what it takes to get there. Like I enjoy hiking and often think of doing a thru-hike on the Appalachian or Pacific Coast trail - but would I really enjoy being out there for SIX months?!? Are they just "ego goals"? <<<
This is precisely why I like the well-formed goal idea. When I did my goal setting exercises, a la Lakein I took a lot of time formulating them. IOW, after I had the basic list from the exercises, I paid a lot of attention to the six-month list. (After thinking more about it from our last exchange, it dawned on me that it is precisely the six-month question that brings into focus LONG TERM goals, rather than short. The question is not do you want to DO in the next six months, but if you ONLY HAD six months, what would be the most IMPORTANT things you could accomplish in those last months? That is a question of ultimate importance rather than one of immediate gratification.)
But to continue (squirrel! ;-) once the goal was identified, and fleshed out according to the general principles of well-formedness (specific, time limited, etc.) I wrote several paragraphs describing my outcome. IOW, I described how it would be to have accomplished it, why I wanted to do it, what I would have gotten from it, etc. I feel that helps in separating the pie-in-the-sky things from those which are really meaningful.
It is still possible for crap to get through that filter. But to do so it would have to be something like: "I want to climb Mt. Everest so my buddies will have their jaws hanging open." O.K. for the day on which you write the goal, but over time, as you start to plan the milestones and projects and tasks, rereading that REASON for doing the thing kind of brings into focus that maybe I don't REALLY want to climb the mountain, but rather just make others feel incompetent compared to me. Then I'm more likely to question my motives and overall mental health ;-)
I am what some here are lately calling a scanner, I guess. I have gobs of interests and tend to be wider than deep. Whatever the reasons for that (and I must say that I'm not a big fan of reasons for motivation) I find that I need to be very careful to understand my reasons for doing a project ... the more so if it will take lots of time and effort. EVERYTHING seems fun to do ... but time is not infinite and not everything will have a high pay back.
A second thing here is that one of the classical ways we procrastinate is by this whole relative difficulty idea (which AF uses to some advantage). I am not one to always flee to outright pleasure in order to avoid work ... I'm quite happy to do things that take a LOT of work, so long as it is work that I don't (for my own reasons) despise doing. The implication here is that just doing something, even something that may have great worth, may not be the best use of my time. I want to be doing something that has a high pay back and so I spend considerable time prioritizing goals. Only through prioritizing can I be sure that I am not kidding myself and avoiding doing important things (to which I am resistant) in favor of less important but attractive ones, which nonetheless are still valuable.
Well, it has been unusually hard to get to the internet recently. The silly hotel wanted to charge for internet access. It seems that the Sheraton is living in its own little world. Hell, most McDonald's now have a wi-fi service. Now at my brother-in-law's I find that Comcast is screwing up and needs to replace the drop to the house. But at least there is SOME access ;-(
>>> I wonder how many people dream of doing things like climbing Everest because they love mountain climbing or they just want to be able to say they climbed the big one? I've been wondering lately if some of my goals are like that where I love the idea of doing this grand thing (and they sound impressive too!) more than the process of what it takes to get there. Like I enjoy hiking and often think of doing a thru-hike on the Appalachian or Pacific Coast trail - but would I really enjoy being out there for SIX months?!? Are they just "ego goals"? <<<
This is precisely why I like the well-formed goal idea. When I did my goal setting exercises, a la Lakein I took a lot of time formulating them. IOW, after I had the basic list from the exercises, I paid a lot of attention to the six-month list. (After thinking more about it from our last exchange, it dawned on me that it is precisely the six-month question that brings into focus LONG TERM goals, rather than short. The question is not do you want to DO in the next six months, but if you ONLY HAD six months, what would be the most IMPORTANT things you could accomplish in those last months? That is a question of ultimate importance rather than one of immediate gratification.)
But to continue (squirrel! ;-) once the goal was identified, and fleshed out according to the general principles of well-formedness (specific, time limited, etc.) I wrote several paragraphs describing my outcome. IOW, I described how it would be to have accomplished it, why I wanted to do it, what I would have gotten from it, etc. I feel that helps in separating the pie-in-the-sky things from those which are really meaningful.
It is still possible for crap to get through that filter. But to do so it would have to be something like: "I want to climb Mt. Everest so my buddies will have their jaws hanging open." O.K. for the day on which you write the goal, but over time, as you start to plan the milestones and projects and tasks, rereading that REASON for doing the thing kind of brings into focus that maybe I don't REALLY want to climb the mountain, but rather just make others feel incompetent compared to me. Then I'm more likely to question my motives and overall mental health ;-)
I am what some here are lately calling a scanner, I guess. I have gobs of interests and tend to be wider than deep. Whatever the reasons for that (and I must say that I'm not a big fan of reasons for motivation) I find that I need to be very careful to understand my reasons for doing a project ... the more so if it will take lots of time and effort. EVERYTHING seems fun to do ... but time is not infinite and not everything will have a high pay back.
A second thing here is that one of the classical ways we procrastinate is by this whole relative difficulty idea (which AF uses to some advantage). I am not one to always flee to outright pleasure in order to avoid work ... I'm quite happy to do things that take a LOT of work, so long as it is work that I don't (for my own reasons) despise doing. The implication here is that just doing something, even something that may have great worth, may not be the best use of my time. I want to be doing something that has a high pay back and so I spend considerable time prioritizing goals. Only through prioritizing can I be sure that I am not kidding myself and avoiding doing important things (to which I am resistant) in favor of less important but attractive ones, which nonetheless are still valuable.
Reply by Alan Baljeu
Hotels have been their own world for some time now. After all, why does a beer-fridge drink cost $10, and why does a local phone call sometimes cost $1.50?
Good stuff on goal setting, Mike.
Good stuff on goal setting, Mike.
Reply by Mel
As I near the end of nanowrimo.org, I love this quote, too:
I read a quote by some writer or other (it might have been Azimov) and he said that if he was told he had only one day to live, the only thing he'd change was that he would just type faster.
I wonder if people would feel better about goal-setting if they decided that dropping the goal was success, too. Lately I am just as excited about the goals I've decided not to pursue as the goals I'm still working on.
I don't think everyone is goal-oriented in the same way and even within people, our approach to goals fluctuates. I've achieved goals where I did it the SMART way and goals I've achieved that I approached in a very laid-back way. Right now I have a goal of writing a 50,000 word novel in a month. It's very Lakein-ish. Then I have another goal which is to get better at tennis. I went through a time recently where I considered dropping the goal. The fact that cranky 80yo women were beating me had something to do with that. I'm continuing to move in the general direction of my goal in spite of my humiliation. But I refuse to feel like I failed if I don't continue with it. Some goals shouldn't be pursued and some could be achieved easily if you really wanted them.
When I started AF I became very anxious about my progress on goals. Now I see lack of progress as the best indicator of what I really want. I don't like to think of what I would do if I would die in six months and that's not just because the thought isn't appealing. :-) I prefer a 5 year time-frame. I do think Jacqueline's suggestion of a Bucket List is a fun idea. I just won't be killing myself to complete them all (pun intended).
I read a quote by some writer or other (it might have been Azimov) and he said that if he was told he had only one day to live, the only thing he'd change was that he would just type faster.
I wonder if people would feel better about goal-setting if they decided that dropping the goal was success, too. Lately I am just as excited about the goals I've decided not to pursue as the goals I'm still working on.
I don't think everyone is goal-oriented in the same way and even within people, our approach to goals fluctuates. I've achieved goals where I did it the SMART way and goals I've achieved that I approached in a very laid-back way. Right now I have a goal of writing a 50,000 word novel in a month. It's very Lakein-ish. Then I have another goal which is to get better at tennis. I went through a time recently where I considered dropping the goal. The fact that cranky 80yo women were beating me had something to do with that. I'm continuing to move in the general direction of my goal in spite of my humiliation. But I refuse to feel like I failed if I don't continue with it. Some goals shouldn't be pursued and some could be achieved easily if you really wanted them.
When I started AF I became very anxious about my progress on goals. Now I see lack of progress as the best indicator of what I really want. I don't like to think of what I would do if I would die in six months and that's not just because the thought isn't appealing. :-) I prefer a 5 year time-frame. I do think Jacqueline's suggestion of a Bucket List is a fun idea. I just won't be killing myself to complete them all (pun intended).
Reply by Mike
Good Morning Mel,
That quote by Asimov (if it was him ;-) actually illustrates how successful goals work. It is not that he has no goals, just that he is in nearly perfect alignment with them. IOW, he set his goals and they have held up so well that he can't think of a better way to use his time other than to pursue the ones he has.
As to the bucket list ... IIRC, those two guys were about to die and one had no goals and the point of it all was that he needed them or he would stand no chance at all. So that is yet another case of having and testing goals to be sure you are working on the right ones.
As to the main message in what you say ... I don't know if you have ever seen the TV show "Mythbusters". Adam (the goofy one) is most often seen wearing a T-Shirt with the slogan: "Failure is always an option." That always cracked me up and seems to me to be the essence of the scientific method. Just the other day I was driving through some godforsaken place in the mid-west ;-) and I saw some kind of a slogan for a school or something: "Failure is never an option." I entirely get that, and would have subscribed wholeheartedly in the past ... but this time it took me aback. It got me thinking of exactly what message I'd want to convey to kids. Certainly they already feel that failure is an option, but ... ;-)
That quote by Asimov (if it was him ;-) actually illustrates how successful goals work. It is not that he has no goals, just that he is in nearly perfect alignment with them. IOW, he set his goals and they have held up so well that he can't think of a better way to use his time other than to pursue the ones he has.
As to the bucket list ... IIRC, those two guys were about to die and one had no goals and the point of it all was that he needed them or he would stand no chance at all. So that is yet another case of having and testing goals to be sure you are working on the right ones.
As to the main message in what you say ... I don't know if you have ever seen the TV show "Mythbusters". Adam (the goofy one) is most often seen wearing a T-Shirt with the slogan: "Failure is always an option." That always cracked me up and seems to me to be the essence of the scientific method. Just the other day I was driving through some godforsaken place in the mid-west ;-) and I saw some kind of a slogan for a school or something: "Failure is never an option." I entirely get that, and would have subscribed wholeheartedly in the past ... but this time it took me aback. It got me thinking of exactly what message I'd want to convey to kids. Certainly they already feel that failure is an option, but ... ;-)
Reply by Alan Baljeu
"Failure is an option" has two senses:
1) failure is okay; don't fear it
2) failure is a choice;often you can choose success instead.
Which sense applies depends on the situation. The second sense is what "not an option people" are thinking.
I like what that Perfectionism article suggested: Lower your standards so you can succeed more. By your original standard, that's failure, which perfectionists fear. But it really isn't failure at all. It's just the perception.
1) failure is okay; don't fear it
2) failure is a choice;often you can choose success instead.
Which sense applies depends on the situation. The second sense is what "not an option people" are thinking.
I like what that Perfectionism article suggested: Lower your standards so you can succeed more. By your original standard, that's failure, which perfectionists fear. But it really isn't failure at all. It's just the perception.
Reply by Jacqueline
The 6 month vs. 5 year thing might also impact the *way* you approach the goal even though the goal itself stays the same.
Let's just say I want to declutter my house (which I do). If that was on my 5 year list, I'd methodically go through everything, dropping stuff off at goodwill, having a garage sale and otherwise re-homing things. If I had only 6 months to go, I'd make a pile of everything to keep, throw everything else outside on the sidewalk with a "FREE" sign on it and haul the rest to the dump.
So maybe the message there is to treat my 5 year goal in a way more aligned with my 6 month methods.
I like your "crap filter" ideas Mike. :-) I will definitely set up a filter for the "2010 New Years resolutions" that I do over Xmas.
Mel, maybe tennis would be on your 6 month bucket list - and if it was, it might change to *enjoying* playing tennis more and learn the love of the game rather than focusing on getting better. And by enjoying it more, you probably get better by default.
Let's just say I want to declutter my house (which I do). If that was on my 5 year list, I'd methodically go through everything, dropping stuff off at goodwill, having a garage sale and otherwise re-homing things. If I had only 6 months to go, I'd make a pile of everything to keep, throw everything else outside on the sidewalk with a "FREE" sign on it and haul the rest to the dump.
So maybe the message there is to treat my 5 year goal in a way more aligned with my 6 month methods.
I like your "crap filter" ideas Mike. :-) I will definitely set up a filter for the "2010 New Years resolutions" that I do over Xmas.
Mel, maybe tennis would be on your 6 month bucket list - and if it was, it might change to *enjoying* playing tennis more and learn the love of the game rather than focusing on getting better. And by enjoying it more, you probably get better by default.
Reply by Mike
Alan,
>>> I like what that Perfectionism article suggested: Lower your standards so you can succeed more. By your original standard, that's failure, which perfectionists fear. But it really isn't failure at all. It's just the perception. <<<
So much of this stuff is how you look at it. On the face of it, lowering standards is a bad thing. But what it seems to come down to is what the standards are about. Where we get into big trouble is when we judge ourselves by a too high standard. As someone put it (someone in the NLP world, to be sure) is that depression often ensues because of unrealistically high standards. People who are miserable are often running after these super high goals. The happiest ones are those who's standard of happiness is just waking up above ground.
But none of this works for all people in the same way.
>>> I like what that Perfectionism article suggested: Lower your standards so you can succeed more. By your original standard, that's failure, which perfectionists fear. But it really isn't failure at all. It's just the perception. <<<
So much of this stuff is how you look at it. On the face of it, lowering standards is a bad thing. But what it seems to come down to is what the standards are about. Where we get into big trouble is when we judge ourselves by a too high standard. As someone put it (someone in the NLP world, to be sure) is that depression often ensues because of unrealistically high standards. People who are miserable are often running after these super high goals. The happiest ones are those who's standard of happiness is just waking up above ground.
But none of this works for all people in the same way.
Reply by Mel
Are you sure you guys don't have Ph.D.'s in psychology? ;-)
I love "Failure is always an option" Mike because quite frankly in my life until recently, it hasn't been. I think there are those for whom the opposite slogan could produce rewards. But for me, a very harsh self-critic, the former is more appropriate.
Jacqueline, I think you bring up an excellent point. The time-frame for goals does impact our methods. That is why I like using a longer deadline for some things anyway. The methods I'd adopt for a 6-month deadline are too harsh for some things. Like, I'd get rid of one whole season's worth of clothing if I were going in 6 months. LOL
Love your idea to have "enjoy tennis more" as a goal. I think this is in line with my desire to be patient and positive about it rather than saying, "You look like an idiot"--my usual commentary.
Alan, I have been working toward lowering my standards for the past several months. One of the biggest areas that has had a huge payoff is in terms of productivity.
Mike, I think you're right that the Bucket List guys NEEDED their list to keep them going. I am so thankful that I feel I could die today and have no deep regrets. A few little things I would have wished I'd taken care of, but nothing major. No unquenchable desire to visit a country I haven't visited. I'm content. But I do need to scrub my kitchen floor today. ;-)
I love "Failure is always an option" Mike because quite frankly in my life until recently, it hasn't been. I think there are those for whom the opposite slogan could produce rewards. But for me, a very harsh self-critic, the former is more appropriate.
Jacqueline, I think you bring up an excellent point. The time-frame for goals does impact our methods. That is why I like using a longer deadline for some things anyway. The methods I'd adopt for a 6-month deadline are too harsh for some things. Like, I'd get rid of one whole season's worth of clothing if I were going in 6 months. LOL
Love your idea to have "enjoy tennis more" as a goal. I think this is in line with my desire to be patient and positive about it rather than saying, "You look like an idiot"--my usual commentary.
Alan, I have been working toward lowering my standards for the past several months. One of the biggest areas that has had a huge payoff is in terms of productivity.
Mike, I think you're right that the Bucket List guys NEEDED their list to keep them going. I am so thankful that I feel I could die today and have no deep regrets. A few little things I would have wished I'd taken care of, but nothing major. No unquenchable desire to visit a country I haven't visited. I'm content. But I do need to scrub my kitchen floor today. ;-)
Reply by Jacqueline
Oh Mel, I agree about the 6 month methods being too harsh even for decluttering. I like to be environmentally friendly after all. :-) But I could still learn to be a bit more decisive. Now get out that bucket and wash that floor!
Mel, sometimes I like having my bucket/goal list to rein in myself. For example, I can and do receive emails from travel places regularly on trips to Vegas, Disneyworld and other places I don't really have any interest in. Having written down where I do really want to go somewhere reminds me that Vegas isn't on that list. It's hard to stay mindful of what you really want when faced with temptations from marketers and having it on a list definitely helps.
Mike, are you thinking about Lyndon Duke and the "linguistics of suicide" where he talks about the "curse of exceptionality?" Basically, that some suicidal people expect more out of life than life can realistically give. And expect more out of themselves than they can give too sometimes.
I think I also recall Carol Dweck in her book Mindset talking about "the curse of the exceptional student" - that one hit home and caused a lot of issues for me in my late 20's and early 30's with that perfectionist mindset. But that's another thread.
Mel, sometimes I like having my bucket/goal list to rein in myself. For example, I can and do receive emails from travel places regularly on trips to Vegas, Disneyworld and other places I don't really have any interest in. Having written down where I do really want to go somewhere reminds me that Vegas isn't on that list. It's hard to stay mindful of what you really want when faced with temptations from marketers and having it on a list definitely helps.
Mike, are you thinking about Lyndon Duke and the "linguistics of suicide" where he talks about the "curse of exceptionality?" Basically, that some suicidal people expect more out of life than life can realistically give. And expect more out of themselves than they can give too sometimes.
I think I also recall Carol Dweck in her book Mindset talking about "the curse of the exceptional student" - that one hit home and caused a lot of issues for me in my late 20's and early 30's with that perfectionist mindset. But that's another thread.
Reply by Mike
Mel.
The "Failure is always an option." seems to fit well with these guys. They are both special effects (FX) guys ... they have created lots of the monsters you see in the movies as well as robots for ads and exploding this and that. I can see where having that mindset is very helpful to them. They never know if something will work or not so they just have to try it and keep on tinkering and in the end, settle for a new approach. (And, BTW, they are not drunken morons like some of their imitators. They really can do the math and design the project before they start. Great show!)
Jacqueline,
No, it did not come from those sources. It was someone in the NLP world, for sure. Perhaps several. NLP has modeled what works for people. IOW, if you want to be a successful student, find a successful (better if you do it with many) and interview them very carefully to discover what they do that works. Then do that yourself. (I say carefully because they seldom know the key and much of what they tell you sounds good but is irrelevant.)
In this particular case they wondered what makes people happy and one of the key points is having a low standard for happiness. Some people need to crush someone in business to be happy. Some need to make lots of money. The people who are MOST happy ... I mean happy PEOPLE, not just people BEING happy ... are those who will be happy for just about any reason. They are happy to just be alive. They don't have lots of conditions they need to meet in order to feel happy. We have all met those people ... truth be told, they often annoy ;-) But they are just anthropomorphizied sunshine. My wife is a bit like that. She has this wonderful smile that, once she is up in the morning (because there is nothing happy about mornings for her ;-) she turns on and it lights the world up.
Another way to look at it is that some people need a reason to be happy, others need a reason to be sad.
Speaking of NLP, I am chomping at the bit to finish Ellis so I can get to "The Emotional Hostage" again. In it they model the components of emotion and I'm looking forward to seeing what they did for procrastination. IIRC, they did not address processes so much as real emotion so I'm not hopeful in that regard, but since a sense of inadequacy is key to much of procrastination (especially perfectionism) and hostility to another, I'll bet I am able to add to my compilation of ideas from that source.
Re: Cleaning in six months. You know, I had a very enlightening experience in that regard. One day I was driving home from a road trip and rounded the corner just as I was worrying that all was O.K. with the house while I was gone. In the split second I saw the house (perfectly fine) it dawned on me that I would not be all that brokenhearted if the place burned down (this was before I had furry critters living with me). The thought of losing everything did not seem so awful after all. So why did I have so much STUFF?
The "Failure is always an option." seems to fit well with these guys. They are both special effects (FX) guys ... they have created lots of the monsters you see in the movies as well as robots for ads and exploding this and that. I can see where having that mindset is very helpful to them. They never know if something will work or not so they just have to try it and keep on tinkering and in the end, settle for a new approach. (And, BTW, they are not drunken morons like some of their imitators. They really can do the math and design the project before they start. Great show!)
Jacqueline,
No, it did not come from those sources. It was someone in the NLP world, for sure. Perhaps several. NLP has modeled what works for people. IOW, if you want to be a successful student, find a successful (better if you do it with many) and interview them very carefully to discover what they do that works. Then do that yourself. (I say carefully because they seldom know the key and much of what they tell you sounds good but is irrelevant.)
In this particular case they wondered what makes people happy and one of the key points is having a low standard for happiness. Some people need to crush someone in business to be happy. Some need to make lots of money. The people who are MOST happy ... I mean happy PEOPLE, not just people BEING happy ... are those who will be happy for just about any reason. They are happy to just be alive. They don't have lots of conditions they need to meet in order to feel happy. We have all met those people ... truth be told, they often annoy ;-) But they are just anthropomorphizied sunshine. My wife is a bit like that. She has this wonderful smile that, once she is up in the morning (because there is nothing happy about mornings for her ;-) she turns on and it lights the world up.
Another way to look at it is that some people need a reason to be happy, others need a reason to be sad.
Speaking of NLP, I am chomping at the bit to finish Ellis so I can get to "The Emotional Hostage" again. In it they model the components of emotion and I'm looking forward to seeing what they did for procrastination. IIRC, they did not address processes so much as real emotion so I'm not hopeful in that regard, but since a sense of inadequacy is key to much of procrastination (especially perfectionism) and hostility to another, I'll bet I am able to add to my compilation of ideas from that source.
Re: Cleaning in six months. You know, I had a very enlightening experience in that regard. One day I was driving home from a road trip and rounded the corner just as I was worrying that all was O.K. with the house while I was gone. In the split second I saw the house (perfectly fine) it dawned on me that I would not be all that brokenhearted if the place burned down (this was before I had furry critters living with me). The thought of losing everything did not seem so awful after all. So why did I have so much STUFF?
Reply by Mel
Great stuff, you two. It DOES help me to know what I want so I can filter out everything I don't. I am going to consider a bucket list, but have to decide on a time frame. Even a places-I-want-to-go list would work.
A low standard for happiness. That's it. I couldn't figure out why my easy-going, always content girlfriends could be okay with not dusting for example. Or not making five salads for a dinner party when just one would do. I've always felt compelled to do more.
As for determining what makes a person successful, we're nearly always wrong. Even when we're given the right answer, we tend to dismiss it. Why is Tiger Woods so good at golf? Because he started playing at 2. No, that's not it. It's the clubs. LOL
Another mental technique I've used for determining what I really need to keep is to imagine that I'm going to live in a small condo for a couple of years. What would I really need? Mike, you wouldn't be sad about losing your pictures and mementos?
A low standard for happiness. That's it. I couldn't figure out why my easy-going, always content girlfriends could be okay with not dusting for example. Or not making five salads for a dinner party when just one would do. I've always felt compelled to do more.
As for determining what makes a person successful, we're nearly always wrong. Even when we're given the right answer, we tend to dismiss it. Why is Tiger Woods so good at golf? Because he started playing at 2. No, that's not it. It's the clubs. LOL
Another mental technique I've used for determining what I really need to keep is to imagine that I'm going to live in a small condo for a couple of years. What would I really need? Mike, you wouldn't be sad about losing your pictures and mementos?
Reply by Mike
Happy gobble-gobble day to you Mel,
I'm doing a last few minutes of gossiping here before I pack up the car for travel back to a (presumably still standing) home ;-)
>>> Great stuff, you two. It DOES help me to know what I want so I can filter out everything I don't. I am going to consider a bucket list, but have to decide on a time frame. Even a places-I-want-to-go list would work. <<<
The "bucket list" is just one of those pop catch phrases for a list of lifetime goals. I really REALLY suggest to anyone that doing the exercies in the Lakein book will be life changing. It will take some days to do it right. I'd start now and hope to be done my the first of the year. Yes, if you do it right it takes time. Not whole gobs of dedicated times, but many sessions of review and tweaking.
The thing about doing that. Is that you CAN end up with a list of lifetime goals broken down by intermediate milestones. When I did mine I wound up with:
- Lifetime
- 20 Years
- 10 Years
- 5 Years
- 3 Years
- 1 Year
- 6 Months
- 3 Months
- 1 Month
- Weekly
With that kind of a structure, the long term goals were supported by the shorter term ones and on my weekly reviews I only had to look at my one month list to get it worked out. Monthly I only needed to look at my 3 months list to keep that in shape. Periodically I would look at the longer frames and generally tweak things ... but not often. The longer term goals take care of themselves if you have them fully supported by the short term ones.
And please note, there is no MUST in any of it. If you don't feel like working on tasks this week (or for several months) that support some 10 year goal, who cares? The only thing is that you will at least KNOW what you are doing ... and perhaps decide that your long term goals have changed.
>>> A low standard for happiness. That's it. I couldn't figure out why my easy-going, always content girlfriends could be okay with not dusting for example. Or not making five salads for a dinner party when just one would do. I've always felt compelled to do more. <<<
Yes. It is so easy to hear that as a "low PERSONAL standard". But it is only low as regards to what will make you HAPPY. A good example was my packing for this trip. I took several books, my notebook computer, pads of paper, an assortment of pens ... you know how it goes ;-) I'm at the end of my trip now and have only worked on ONE of the books I brought. I briefly scanned another. I have made good notes on the first but not done the mind map I really want. I have not done a second read yet either. I've touched nothing else. BUT ... I am quite content with what I've done. I am not chewing my nails in angst over my miserable failure as a human being because I have not even looked at the other SIX books I hauled along in the car ;-) ;-)
"But if you accept such a short fall you'll never get anything done!" Errr... so what? I'm not living this life to prove things to people. I'm getting done what I want to get done as revised by life's events. What else can any of us do and retain our sanity? ;-)
>>> As for determining what makes a person successful, we're nearly always wrong. Even when we're given the right answer, we tend to dismiss it. Why is Tiger Woods so good at golf? Because he started playing at 2. No, that's not it. It's the clubs. LOL <<<
Well, the problem is that there are so many standards for success. Likely as not Tiger is successful because he started so young and his standard for being a "good person" in the eyes of his father was to excel at golf. Starting that young probably installed that so deeply in his subconscious that now the basic standard of happiness for him is golf. Just speculating, of course ... he is not about to reveal that much about himself.
>>> Another mental technique I've used for determining what I really need to keep is to imagine that I'm going to live in a small condo for a couple of years. What would I really need? Mike, you wouldn't be sad about losing your pictures and mementos? <<<
Well, to start with, remember that I'm an E5w6. We don't get that much attached to things. We CAN, in a WAY. It is hard to describe. I do have lots of STUFF that I am attached to, but that is only at the surface. I could walk away from it all and live on an island in the South Pacific with only a stick to draw on the sand with. I really could, as odd as that might sound to some. I'd miss my books for a bit, but most of that stuff is in my mind now and I mostly just make new connections among the material I already have in there. I find that there is very little new under the sun and after all these years, I've seen and heard most of it.
I'd miss my cats though. I HAVE to have my cats ;-)
I'm doing a last few minutes of gossiping here before I pack up the car for travel back to a (presumably still standing) home ;-)
>>> Great stuff, you two. It DOES help me to know what I want so I can filter out everything I don't. I am going to consider a bucket list, but have to decide on a time frame. Even a places-I-want-to-go list would work. <<<
The "bucket list" is just one of those pop catch phrases for a list of lifetime goals. I really REALLY suggest to anyone that doing the exercies in the Lakein book will be life changing. It will take some days to do it right. I'd start now and hope to be done my the first of the year. Yes, if you do it right it takes time. Not whole gobs of dedicated times, but many sessions of review and tweaking.
The thing about doing that. Is that you CAN end up with a list of lifetime goals broken down by intermediate milestones. When I did mine I wound up with:
- Lifetime
- 20 Years
- 10 Years
- 5 Years
- 3 Years
- 1 Year
- 6 Months
- 3 Months
- 1 Month
- Weekly
With that kind of a structure, the long term goals were supported by the shorter term ones and on my weekly reviews I only had to look at my one month list to get it worked out. Monthly I only needed to look at my 3 months list to keep that in shape. Periodically I would look at the longer frames and generally tweak things ... but not often. The longer term goals take care of themselves if you have them fully supported by the short term ones.
And please note, there is no MUST in any of it. If you don't feel like working on tasks this week (or for several months) that support some 10 year goal, who cares? The only thing is that you will at least KNOW what you are doing ... and perhaps decide that your long term goals have changed.
>>> A low standard for happiness. That's it. I couldn't figure out why my easy-going, always content girlfriends could be okay with not dusting for example. Or not making five salads for a dinner party when just one would do. I've always felt compelled to do more. <<<
Yes. It is so easy to hear that as a "low PERSONAL standard". But it is only low as regards to what will make you HAPPY. A good example was my packing for this trip. I took several books, my notebook computer, pads of paper, an assortment of pens ... you know how it goes ;-) I'm at the end of my trip now and have only worked on ONE of the books I brought. I briefly scanned another. I have made good notes on the first but not done the mind map I really want. I have not done a second read yet either. I've touched nothing else. BUT ... I am quite content with what I've done. I am not chewing my nails in angst over my miserable failure as a human being because I have not even looked at the other SIX books I hauled along in the car ;-) ;-)
"But if you accept such a short fall you'll never get anything done!" Errr... so what? I'm not living this life to prove things to people. I'm getting done what I want to get done as revised by life's events. What else can any of us do and retain our sanity? ;-)
>>> As for determining what makes a person successful, we're nearly always wrong. Even when we're given the right answer, we tend to dismiss it. Why is Tiger Woods so good at golf? Because he started playing at 2. No, that's not it. It's the clubs. LOL <<<
Well, the problem is that there are so many standards for success. Likely as not Tiger is successful because he started so young and his standard for being a "good person" in the eyes of his father was to excel at golf. Starting that young probably installed that so deeply in his subconscious that now the basic standard of happiness for him is golf. Just speculating, of course ... he is not about to reveal that much about himself.
>>> Another mental technique I've used for determining what I really need to keep is to imagine that I'm going to live in a small condo for a couple of years. What would I really need? Mike, you wouldn't be sad about losing your pictures and mementos? <<<
Well, to start with, remember that I'm an E5w6. We don't get that much attached to things. We CAN, in a WAY. It is hard to describe. I do have lots of STUFF that I am attached to, but that is only at the surface. I could walk away from it all and live on an island in the South Pacific with only a stick to draw on the sand with. I really could, as odd as that might sound to some. I'd miss my books for a bit, but most of that stuff is in my mind now and I mostly just make new connections among the material I already have in there. I find that there is very little new under the sun and after all these years, I've seen and heard most of it.
I'd miss my cats though. I HAVE to have my cats ;-)
Reply by Mel
Mike, happy Thanksgiving! And safe travels.
I've read Lakein (on your recommendation) and other stuff like this and the problem I have right now is that I no longer have the same goal-driven mindset I once had. I used to LOVE that stuff. I would spend my vacation filling notebooks with goals using every time frame. Now I can't think of any lifetime goals I have that lend themselves to that framework. For example, I want to raise and educate my kids well. I want to have a lower standard for happiness and go easier on myself.
I've done everything that I really, really wanted to do: got a Ph.D., got married, had kids, homeschooled, had a baby at home, taught in the university, wrote a book, became a speaker, gotten in great shape, developed lots and lots of programs and coordinated tons of events. I've traveled around the world. I've read lots of books. Now I'm working on a goal that wasn't even a burning passion--writing a novel. I do love it and don't know where it will lead, but I could also be okay if it didn't go anywhere.
There are other things I could pursue, sure. But nothing I feel like I want to approach in a Lakein way. And I don't feel depressed or even unmotivated. I just feel content. See I WAS living to prove things to people. Now I'm not. I'm more of an in-the-moment gal than I used to be. I'm a lot like the people I used to look down on--how can they have such low standards? lol Ummm, because they're content!
I'm getting less dependent on my things, too. I always had a list of things I wanted. Now I don't. I have gotten nearly everything I've ever wanted and so many of those things I don't even use. I do enjoy many of them, but the attachment to them is gone.
Guess what I'm trying to say is that I'm changing. Not having the usual family celebration for Thanksgiving has been great. Every year I've had a houseful and was up at 6 a.m. getting the bird in the oven. This year, the turkey is half the size so I could stuff it when my kids were up. What I was missing all those other years of trying to make everything just so for people who honestly don't give a rip about me! Instead I got to experience the joy of my 4yo asking, "Is that turkey dead? He can't hear you talking? What's that red thing? Look at the stuffing! Eww!" LOL It's not the kind of thing that will ever be on a list, is it?
I've read Lakein (on your recommendation) and other stuff like this and the problem I have right now is that I no longer have the same goal-driven mindset I once had. I used to LOVE that stuff. I would spend my vacation filling notebooks with goals using every time frame. Now I can't think of any lifetime goals I have that lend themselves to that framework. For example, I want to raise and educate my kids well. I want to have a lower standard for happiness and go easier on myself.
I've done everything that I really, really wanted to do: got a Ph.D., got married, had kids, homeschooled, had a baby at home, taught in the university, wrote a book, became a speaker, gotten in great shape, developed lots and lots of programs and coordinated tons of events. I've traveled around the world. I've read lots of books. Now I'm working on a goal that wasn't even a burning passion--writing a novel. I do love it and don't know where it will lead, but I could also be okay if it didn't go anywhere.
There are other things I could pursue, sure. But nothing I feel like I want to approach in a Lakein way. And I don't feel depressed or even unmotivated. I just feel content. See I WAS living to prove things to people. Now I'm not. I'm more of an in-the-moment gal than I used to be. I'm a lot like the people I used to look down on--how can they have such low standards? lol Ummm, because they're content!
I'm getting less dependent on my things, too. I always had a list of things I wanted. Now I don't. I have gotten nearly everything I've ever wanted and so many of those things I don't even use. I do enjoy many of them, but the attachment to them is gone.
Guess what I'm trying to say is that I'm changing. Not having the usual family celebration for Thanksgiving has been great. Every year I've had a houseful and was up at 6 a.m. getting the bird in the oven. This year, the turkey is half the size so I could stuff it when my kids were up. What I was missing all those other years of trying to make everything just so for people who honestly don't give a rip about me! Instead I got to experience the joy of my 4yo asking, "Is that turkey dead? He can't hear you talking? What's that red thing? Look at the stuffing! Eww!" LOL It's not the kind of thing that will ever be on a list, is it?
Reply by Jacqueline
I'll throw it out there that Tiger Woods became Tiger Woods in part through Earl Woods being an estie. I thought this was interesting:
“What I learned through est was that by doing more for myself, I could do much more for others. Yes, be responsible, but love life, and give people the space to be in your life, and allow yourself room to give to others. That caring and sharing is what’s most important, not being responsible for everyone else. Which is where Tiger comes in. What I learned led me to give so much time to Tiger, and to give him the space to be himself, and not to smother him with dos and don’ts. I took out the authority aspect and turned it into companionship. I made myself vulnerable as a parent. When you have to earn respect from your child, rather than demanding it because it’s owed to you as the father, miracles happen. I realized that, through him, the giving could take a quantum leap. What I could do on a limited scale, he could do on a global scale.”
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/features/1996/sportsman/1996.html
“What I learned through est was that by doing more for myself, I could do much more for others. Yes, be responsible, but love life, and give people the space to be in your life, and allow yourself room to give to others. That caring and sharing is what’s most important, not being responsible for everyone else. Which is where Tiger comes in. What I learned led me to give so much time to Tiger, and to give him the space to be himself, and not to smother him with dos and don’ts. I took out the authority aspect and turned it into companionship. I made myself vulnerable as a parent. When you have to earn respect from your child, rather than demanding it because it’s owed to you as the father, miracles happen. I realized that, through him, the giving could take a quantum leap. What I could do on a limited scale, he could do on a global scale.”
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/features/1996/sportsman/1996.html
Reply by Mark Forster
Jacqueline:
"Tiger Woods became Tiger Woods in part through Earl Woods being an estie"
That raises two questions in my mind:
1) There are lots of outstanding sportspersons other than Tiger Woods. Did they all become what they were for the same reason?
2) What about all the people whose father was an estie and who didn't become the equivalent of Tiger Woods?
"Tiger Woods became Tiger Woods in part through Earl Woods being an estie"
That raises two questions in my mind:
1) There are lots of outstanding sportspersons other than Tiger Woods. Did they all become what they were for the same reason?
2) What about all the people whose father was an estie and who didn't become the equivalent of Tiger Woods?
Reply by Jacqueline
Oh sorry Mark, I was being kind of facetious. That's just one of the things he attributed it to, obviously it's a combination of athleticism, an inner drive, parents who could/did spend a lot of time nurturing that talent etc. etc. I know for sure that Walter Gretzky wasn't into est but Wayne turned out pretty ok.
I don't know a thing about golf, and that article and Mark McCormack's books are all I know about golf period. I just thought it was interesting how the dad devoted his whole life to raising a good person and a great golfer.
He also seemed to have the 'seeing the path/goal by looking backwards' that you've mentioned before.
I don't know a thing about golf, and that article and Mark McCormack's books are all I know about golf period. I just thought it was interesting how the dad devoted his whole life to raising a good person and a great golfer.
He also seemed to have the 'seeing the path/goal by looking backwards' that you've mentioned before.
Reply by Mark Forster
Jacqueline
I'm always a bit wary about looking at someone who's succeeded in any field and then trying to identify factors in their success in isolation. Unless you look at a wide range of people it's difficult to determine which factors really were determinant.
For instance, I attended a lecture by a successful businessman who talked about the business gambles he had taken. You might suppose that the message to learn was that one should be prepared to take risks in business. But suppose ten people exactly like him had taken the same risks and for nine the gamble had failed? The one we invite to lecture us will be the one out of the ten who won the gamble. We won't invite the nine who did exactly the same but failed.
I'm always a bit wary about looking at someone who's succeeded in any field and then trying to identify factors in their success in isolation. Unless you look at a wide range of people it's difficult to determine which factors really were determinant.
For instance, I attended a lecture by a successful businessman who talked about the business gambles he had taken. You might suppose that the message to learn was that one should be prepared to take risks in business. But suppose ten people exactly like him had taken the same risks and for nine the gamble had failed? The one we invite to lecture us will be the one out of the ten who won the gamble. We won't invite the nine who did exactly the same but failed.
Reply by Mike
Good Morning Mark,
Yes, exactly. People who are successful don't really know what it is that they do to be successful. Like all of us, they just do what seems natural to them. Some of that causes their success, much of it is just neutral in regard to the particular success they have, and a bit of it works against their success and actually causes them problems.
In addition, if you take a person with a different personality and have him try to apply even those things which you KNOW (putting aside HOW you know it for a second) are responsible for this person's success, they might well be the ruination of the second person. Which is to say that you SHOULD invite the nine who failed!
Beside not knowing what is really responsible for his success, many successful people do not WANT to share ... they see their ability as valuable and don't want to give it away to others. And they do this (not share) by giving misleading information ... consciously or not.
The way you get the information, IMO, is to "model" them. You do this by interviewing many people who have a certain "type" of success. For example, you might interview many business people. To be more accurate, you might limit your study sample to only salesperson's and try to isolate what makes THEM successful. Really, "success in business" is far to broad to model. Salesmen don't have (or need) exactly the same skills as CEOs. In addition, real estate sales people share common basic sales skills with "route salesmen" but have skills unique to that kind of selling. Selling door-to-door is different than selling multi-million dollar items to CEOs.
To do the interview, one has to develop experience in doing exactly that "type" of interview. IOW, one has to have an idea of the most general kinds of things that make people "successful" in whatever they do. (And in this context "success" includes getting results that no one would rationally want ... like psychological disorders. Success only means "efficiently and reliably getting SOME outcome".)
So knowing how people produce results "in general" leads you to know what kinds of questions to ask and where to look. Knowing that, you are able to get a profile of each person and then compare them to each other to find out what is common. For example, in interviewing one baseball star you get a pile of information including that he always wears the same socks without washing them for the whole season. (Ewwww!) No other players do that ... so you throw it out of your list of reasons for success. But looking very deeply at them you might find that each has something similar ... one might tap his bat on his shoe exactly three times, another might cross himself, another spit, etc. Now clearly none of those could be responsible for his success, but perhaps having SOME ritual is what is important ... since all of them do it. In addition, experience in modeling would lead you to notice that quickly and you'd know to ask the right questions to uncover what they are all "feeling" when they are putting on dirty socks or spitting. You'd have learned that it is not so much what they DO, but what that means to them that has importance.
If you wanted to be thorough you might interview baseball players who completely sucked at it. To do it even better you might formulate a theory of "success in baseball" and then, after interviewing successes, then the failures, try training one of the failures according to what you learned from the successful ones and see if you could cause improvement. Basically it is a science project. The problem with success literature is that it is all allegorical. The successful ones write books about themselves which make them important (and make them money) and they don't really know or care what made them successful.
Yes, exactly. People who are successful don't really know what it is that they do to be successful. Like all of us, they just do what seems natural to them. Some of that causes their success, much of it is just neutral in regard to the particular success they have, and a bit of it works against their success and actually causes them problems.
In addition, if you take a person with a different personality and have him try to apply even those things which you KNOW (putting aside HOW you know it for a second) are responsible for this person's success, they might well be the ruination of the second person. Which is to say that you SHOULD invite the nine who failed!
Beside not knowing what is really responsible for his success, many successful people do not WANT to share ... they see their ability as valuable and don't want to give it away to others. And they do this (not share) by giving misleading information ... consciously or not.
The way you get the information, IMO, is to "model" them. You do this by interviewing many people who have a certain "type" of success. For example, you might interview many business people. To be more accurate, you might limit your study sample to only salesperson's and try to isolate what makes THEM successful. Really, "success in business" is far to broad to model. Salesmen don't have (or need) exactly the same skills as CEOs. In addition, real estate sales people share common basic sales skills with "route salesmen" but have skills unique to that kind of selling. Selling door-to-door is different than selling multi-million dollar items to CEOs.
To do the interview, one has to develop experience in doing exactly that "type" of interview. IOW, one has to have an idea of the most general kinds of things that make people "successful" in whatever they do. (And in this context "success" includes getting results that no one would rationally want ... like psychological disorders. Success only means "efficiently and reliably getting SOME outcome".)
So knowing how people produce results "in general" leads you to know what kinds of questions to ask and where to look. Knowing that, you are able to get a profile of each person and then compare them to each other to find out what is common. For example, in interviewing one baseball star you get a pile of information including that he always wears the same socks without washing them for the whole season. (Ewwww!) No other players do that ... so you throw it out of your list of reasons for success. But looking very deeply at them you might find that each has something similar ... one might tap his bat on his shoe exactly three times, another might cross himself, another spit, etc. Now clearly none of those could be responsible for his success, but perhaps having SOME ritual is what is important ... since all of them do it. In addition, experience in modeling would lead you to notice that quickly and you'd know to ask the right questions to uncover what they are all "feeling" when they are putting on dirty socks or spitting. You'd have learned that it is not so much what they DO, but what that means to them that has importance.
If you wanted to be thorough you might interview baseball players who completely sucked at it. To do it even better you might formulate a theory of "success in baseball" and then, after interviewing successes, then the failures, try training one of the failures according to what you learned from the successful ones and see if you could cause improvement. Basically it is a science project. The problem with success literature is that it is all allegorical. The successful ones write books about themselves which make them important (and make them money) and they don't really know or care what made them successful.
Reply by Mike
Good Morning Mel,
>>> Mike, happy Thanksgiving! And safe travels. <<<
Thank you. I made it home in one piece. I was answering a post here before I left and then a squirll was traveling the elictric power super highway in the sky, made a wrong turn, got fried, and took out a pole transformer in the process. Of course, while my laptop continued to work the router did not and I had to pack it up and leave things incomplete. It was THAT kind of trip ;-( But otherwise I enjoyed it ;-)
>>> I've read Lakein (on your recommendation) and other stuff like this and the problem I have right now is that I no longer have the same goal-driven mindset I once had. I used to LOVE that stuff. I would spend my vacation filling notebooks with goals using every time frame. Now I can't think of any lifetime goals I have that lend themselves to that framework. <<<
Sounds just like me ;-)
>>> For example, I want to raise and educate my kids well. I want to have a lower standard for happiness and go easier on myself. <<<
But of course, raising the kids well is an important goal that might benefit from some planning. I dunno. I don't have kids ... just cats ;-) But I do get your point.
>>> I've done everything that I really, really wanted to do: got a Ph.D., got married, had kids, homeschooled, had a baby at home, taught in the university, wrote a book, became a speaker, gotten in great shape, developed lots and lots of programs and coordinated tons of events. I've traveled around the world. I've read lots of books. Now I'm working on a goal that wasn't even a burning passion--writing a novel. I do love it and don't know where it will lead, but I could also be okay if it didn't go anywhere. <<<
Actually, I get that. If you have accomplished a lot of things, then you know what goals are and when you need to define them explicitly and when not. Moreover, as in that Asimov quote, if you have worked your goals into your lifestyle, there may indeed be nothing more to do but more of the same.
>>> There are other things I could pursue, sure. But nothing I feel like I want to approach in a Lakein way. And I don't feel depressed or even unmotivated. I just feel content. See I WAS living to prove things to people. Now I'm not. I'm more of an in-the-moment gal than I used to be. I'm a lot like the people I used to look down on--how can they have such low standards? lol Ummm, because they're content! <<<
LOL ;-) Yes the key is happiness. There is noting at all wrong with "Margaretaville" lifestyle.
>>> I'm getting less dependent on my things, too. I always had a list of things I wanted. Now I don't. I have gotten nearly everything I've ever wanted and so many of those things I don't even use. I do enjoy many of them, but the attachment to them is gone. <<<
Yes, that is it with me as well. My wife has finally stopped asking me what I want for Xmas. And I her. We know that we will get what we want if we really want it but otherwise we don't want things just to have things. We are going to get a sound system this year. It is not a burning desire, but her life is music and she should have the highest quality music that is financially reasonable. Over the holidays she was playing Wii Tennis and seemed to really love DOING that. So I might get her a Wii system, not to HAVE it but to DO it. That is the difference I see.
>>> Guess what I'm trying to say is that I'm changing. Not having the usual family celebration for Thanksgiving has been great. Every year I've had a houseful and was up at 6 a.m. getting the bird in the oven. This year, the turkey is half the size so I could stuff it when my kids were up. What I was missing all those other years of trying to make everything just so for people who honestly don't give a rip about me! Instead I got to experience the joy of my 4yo asking, "Is that turkey dead? He can't hear you talking? What's that red thing? Look at the stuffing! Eww!" LOL It's not the kind of thing that will ever be on a list, is it? <<<
No, not at all ;-) But if I were going to raise a child I WOULD have made a major project of learning the best ways to equip the child for whatever kind of success he could have ... as well as finding the best ways to help him experience enough things to be able to decide.
Unlike Tiger Wood's father, I would not be trying to make my kid into something to fulfill my own dreams. IOW, I might see to it that the kid had all kinds of physical experiences, but I would not have him playing golf everyday at the age of two ... unless he threw a tantrum when I took away his clubs. Then I'd take that as a sign ;-)
O.K. A couple more of these and then off to my year end projects lists ;-)
>>> Mike, happy Thanksgiving! And safe travels. <<<
Thank you. I made it home in one piece. I was answering a post here before I left and then a squirll was traveling the elictric power super highway in the sky, made a wrong turn, got fried, and took out a pole transformer in the process. Of course, while my laptop continued to work the router did not and I had to pack it up and leave things incomplete. It was THAT kind of trip ;-( But otherwise I enjoyed it ;-)
>>> I've read Lakein (on your recommendation) and other stuff like this and the problem I have right now is that I no longer have the same goal-driven mindset I once had. I used to LOVE that stuff. I would spend my vacation filling notebooks with goals using every time frame. Now I can't think of any lifetime goals I have that lend themselves to that framework. <<<
Sounds just like me ;-)
>>> For example, I want to raise and educate my kids well. I want to have a lower standard for happiness and go easier on myself. <<<
But of course, raising the kids well is an important goal that might benefit from some planning. I dunno. I don't have kids ... just cats ;-) But I do get your point.
>>> I've done everything that I really, really wanted to do: got a Ph.D., got married, had kids, homeschooled, had a baby at home, taught in the university, wrote a book, became a speaker, gotten in great shape, developed lots and lots of programs and coordinated tons of events. I've traveled around the world. I've read lots of books. Now I'm working on a goal that wasn't even a burning passion--writing a novel. I do love it and don't know where it will lead, but I could also be okay if it didn't go anywhere. <<<
Actually, I get that. If you have accomplished a lot of things, then you know what goals are and when you need to define them explicitly and when not. Moreover, as in that Asimov quote, if you have worked your goals into your lifestyle, there may indeed be nothing more to do but more of the same.
>>> There are other things I could pursue, sure. But nothing I feel like I want to approach in a Lakein way. And I don't feel depressed or even unmotivated. I just feel content. See I WAS living to prove things to people. Now I'm not. I'm more of an in-the-moment gal than I used to be. I'm a lot like the people I used to look down on--how can they have such low standards? lol Ummm, because they're content! <<<
LOL ;-) Yes the key is happiness. There is noting at all wrong with "Margaretaville" lifestyle.
>>> I'm getting less dependent on my things, too. I always had a list of things I wanted. Now I don't. I have gotten nearly everything I've ever wanted and so many of those things I don't even use. I do enjoy many of them, but the attachment to them is gone. <<<
Yes, that is it with me as well. My wife has finally stopped asking me what I want for Xmas. And I her. We know that we will get what we want if we really want it but otherwise we don't want things just to have things. We are going to get a sound system this year. It is not a burning desire, but her life is music and she should have the highest quality music that is financially reasonable. Over the holidays she was playing Wii Tennis and seemed to really love DOING that. So I might get her a Wii system, not to HAVE it but to DO it. That is the difference I see.
>>> Guess what I'm trying to say is that I'm changing. Not having the usual family celebration for Thanksgiving has been great. Every year I've had a houseful and was up at 6 a.m. getting the bird in the oven. This year, the turkey is half the size so I could stuff it when my kids were up. What I was missing all those other years of trying to make everything just so for people who honestly don't give a rip about me! Instead I got to experience the joy of my 4yo asking, "Is that turkey dead? He can't hear you talking? What's that red thing? Look at the stuffing! Eww!" LOL It's not the kind of thing that will ever be on a list, is it? <<<
No, not at all ;-) But if I were going to raise a child I WOULD have made a major project of learning the best ways to equip the child for whatever kind of success he could have ... as well as finding the best ways to help him experience enough things to be able to decide.
Unlike Tiger Wood's father, I would not be trying to make my kid into something to fulfill my own dreams. IOW, I might see to it that the kid had all kinds of physical experiences, but I would not have him playing golf everyday at the age of two ... unless he threw a tantrum when I took away his clubs. Then I'd take that as a sign ;-)
O.K. A couple more of these and then off to my year end projects lists ;-)
Reply by Mike
Mel,
Oh, one more thing ...when I recommend Lakein for goal setting, I have in mind someone who has never set goals before. Like you, I have done all of that and I'm now in maintenance mode. Were I to get "the bad news" next week, I'd not go out and buy gear for some new project ... I'd know what to drop and what to spend the rest of my short and valuable time on.
You and I (and some others) are in a different boat than others who are struggling with finding themselves.
For example, I was looking for a better task management system because I was losing time. I knew that because I was monitoring goals and knew things were taking longer than they should. I knew that because I HAD goals. I knew AF would work (as soon as I read about it) because I've done task management any number of ways over the years so I have a well developed intuition in that regard. I knew I had problems with AF the same way. And I knew that I COULD fix them without throwing out the whole system for the same reasons,
Now I'm tackling procrastination head on and I have the same intuitions to guide me there so I'll have that under control soon enough ... AND, I'll navigate the inevitable false starts because of the same kind of intuition based on the same life experiences.
To those "young 'uns" ;-) out there who are struggling, let me just say: "Be of good cheer, it DOES get easier as you go."
Agree, Mel?
Oh, one more thing ...when I recommend Lakein for goal setting, I have in mind someone who has never set goals before. Like you, I have done all of that and I'm now in maintenance mode. Were I to get "the bad news" next week, I'd not go out and buy gear for some new project ... I'd know what to drop and what to spend the rest of my short and valuable time on.
You and I (and some others) are in a different boat than others who are struggling with finding themselves.
For example, I was looking for a better task management system because I was losing time. I knew that because I was monitoring goals and knew things were taking longer than they should. I knew that because I HAD goals. I knew AF would work (as soon as I read about it) because I've done task management any number of ways over the years so I have a well developed intuition in that regard. I knew I had problems with AF the same way. And I knew that I COULD fix them without throwing out the whole system for the same reasons,
Now I'm tackling procrastination head on and I have the same intuitions to guide me there so I'll have that under control soon enough ... AND, I'll navigate the inevitable false starts because of the same kind of intuition based on the same life experiences.
To those "young 'uns" ;-) out there who are struggling, let me just say: "Be of good cheer, it DOES get easier as you go."
Agree, Mel?
Reply by Jacqueline
Mike - I wonder if it's symbolic that the squirrel got fried? :-) As always, if I wait long enough you will say what I'm thinking better than I. It sounds like you've been reading Emotional Hostage. What are you doing method-wise w.r.t. procrastination?
Reply by Mark Forster
Mike:
A couple of things I always wished my parents *had* forced me to do in spite of my reluctance at the time:
1) learn to sing
2) learn a musical instrument
A couple of things I always wished my parents *had* forced me to do in spite of my reluctance at the time:
1) learn to sing
2) learn a musical instrument
Reply by Mel
Mike, I agree. I love the Margaritaville analogy. LOL! That's absolutely where I am. Can't wait to go to Mexico in January and try out my new Spanish speaking skills. The kids and I have been learning together using Visual Link Spanish at a nice steady clip. I've found that for my personality I can learn better with others. Actually, I learn most things best by teaching them.
If you had children, I suspect you would have homeschooled them. It's really the most fulfilling experience. It's an adventure in discovery. Just like TM systems, you can have high hopes that a curriculum will be "the answer" and then your kids say, "We hate it." lol What's fantastic about those moments is that you usually hate it, too. My oldest was asking why he had to keep using the art curriculum when he doesn't like it and doesn't plan to do anything with it in the future. I found myself saying, "Because I had to do it." He didn't even have to say anything before I realized that I needed to let him scrap it.
Now to Mark's point. My second son has a natural giftedness in art and also a naturally unmotivated personality. I asked him what he would like to do when he grows up and he said, "Whatever they want me to do." LOL! So I have had to insist that he continue with the art curriculum. He'll be glad later. Deciding when to push and when to drop these kinds of things is tough. I also don't think we should put the responsibility on our parents though. Sorry Mark! If something is a driving passion, even if you are just a child, you will beg your parents for the opportunity. Otherwise parents will let you go your own way.
Mike, a sound system sounds like a great gift. Dh and I don't exchange gifts either. I love gifts, but I got tired of my dh's habit of giving me torn pieces of yellow notebook paper on Christmas morning saying, "You can buy X." LOL!! Gotta love him. He lets me buy things I really want throughout the year, so it's not right for me to complain. I decided to beg the kids for the one thing I really want anyway (a Wii fitness game). I love your suggestion that a gift of doing is better. Almost everything I'm getting for the kids this year falls in that category. I'm getting lazer tag guns for everyone. The family that shoots at one another stays together, right? ;-)
If you had children, I suspect you would have homeschooled them. It's really the most fulfilling experience. It's an adventure in discovery. Just like TM systems, you can have high hopes that a curriculum will be "the answer" and then your kids say, "We hate it." lol What's fantastic about those moments is that you usually hate it, too. My oldest was asking why he had to keep using the art curriculum when he doesn't like it and doesn't plan to do anything with it in the future. I found myself saying, "Because I had to do it." He didn't even have to say anything before I realized that I needed to let him scrap it.
Now to Mark's point. My second son has a natural giftedness in art and also a naturally unmotivated personality. I asked him what he would like to do when he grows up and he said, "Whatever they want me to do." LOL! So I have had to insist that he continue with the art curriculum. He'll be glad later. Deciding when to push and when to drop these kinds of things is tough. I also don't think we should put the responsibility on our parents though. Sorry Mark! If something is a driving passion, even if you are just a child, you will beg your parents for the opportunity. Otherwise parents will let you go your own way.
Mike, a sound system sounds like a great gift. Dh and I don't exchange gifts either. I love gifts, but I got tired of my dh's habit of giving me torn pieces of yellow notebook paper on Christmas morning saying, "You can buy X." LOL!! Gotta love him. He lets me buy things I really want throughout the year, so it's not right for me to complain. I decided to beg the kids for the one thing I really want anyway (a Wii fitness game). I love your suggestion that a gift of doing is better. Almost everything I'm getting for the kids this year falls in that category. I'm getting lazer tag guns for everyone. The family that shoots at one another stays together, right? ;-)
Reply by Mike
Jacqueline,
>>> Mike - I wonder if it's symbolic that the squirrel got fried? :-) <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I can only hope ;-)
>>> As always, if I wait long enough you will say what I'm thinking better than I. It sounds like you've been reading Emotional Hostage. What are you doing method-wise w.r.t. procrastination? <<<
I've not gotten back to it since the last time. I've not even unpacked yet ;-) The thing about "Emotional Hostage" is that it is not something you "read". It is really more of a workbook, even if not laid out that way. In my first read through I set up the different emotions and the various components they suggest make them up. I tried them out and confirmed that it made sense to me. Then I saw one of those damn squerrils. LOL ;-)
On my next go around, I'll pick up where I left off and tackle the emotions I believe underlie procrastination. Particularly "overwhelm", "frustration", "depression", and those kinds of things. I'll let you know what I learn.
>>> Mike - I wonder if it's symbolic that the squirrel got fried? :-) <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I can only hope ;-)
>>> As always, if I wait long enough you will say what I'm thinking better than I. It sounds like you've been reading Emotional Hostage. What are you doing method-wise w.r.t. procrastination? <<<
I've not gotten back to it since the last time. I've not even unpacked yet ;-) The thing about "Emotional Hostage" is that it is not something you "read". It is really more of a workbook, even if not laid out that way. In my first read through I set up the different emotions and the various components they suggest make them up. I tried them out and confirmed that it made sense to me. Then I saw one of those damn squerrils. LOL ;-)
On my next go around, I'll pick up where I left off and tackle the emotions I believe underlie procrastination. Particularly "overwhelm", "frustration", "depression", and those kinds of things. I'll let you know what I learn.
Reply by Mike
Mark,
Speaking from painful experience, you can NOT "force" a child to learn a musical instrument. I'll have to ask her when she wakes up but I think my wife will confirm that as well.
Speaking from painful experience, you can NOT "force" a child to learn a musical instrument. I'll have to ask her when she wakes up but I think my wife will confirm that as well.
Reply by Mike
Mel,
How the hell are you? ;-)
>>> Mike, I agree. I love the Margaritaville analogy. LOL! That's absolutely where I am. Can't wait to go to Mexico in January and try out my new Spanish speaking skills. The kids and I have been learning together using Visual Link Spanish at a nice steady clip. I've found that for my personality I can learn better with others. Actually, I learn most things best by teaching them. <<<
I'm with you there. In fact, sometimes when I get stuck on something, I imagine that I'm explaining it to someone and that often breaks the mental logjam for me.
As to Spanish, I found that listening to a Spanish radio station all day helped "work it in". There is also a wonderful TV series, called "Destinos". It is a great way to learn the language. It is done as a Spanish soap. A woman attorney is asked to help a dying man find a lover he lost many years ago. In the process, she travels to all of the various Spanish speaking countries and doing that she travels in many ways (thus discussing the words for train, boat, plane, suit case, clothing, money, etc.) It is very well done. It is one of those PBS things. Of course, if you are going in January, I'd just play the radio and TV in Spanish until you go ;-)
>>> If you had children, I suspect you would have homeschooled them. <<<
Every time I hear a news item about a teacher mollesting a child, or worse ... the kinds of idiotic politically correct crap they pass off as education ... I say just that thing.
>>> It's really the most fulfilling experience. It's an adventure in discovery. <<<
I can imagine. I can also imagine how much you learn about the world through new eyes.
>>> Just like TM systems, you can have high hopes that a curriculum will be "the answer" and then your kids say, "We hate it." lol What's fantastic about those moments is that you usually hate it, too. My oldest was asking why he had to keep using the art curriculum when he doesn't like it and doesn't plan to do anything with it in the future. I found myself saying, "Because I had to do it." He didn't even have to say anything before I realized that I needed to let him scrap it. <<<
LOL ;-) That IS neat.
>>> Now to Mark's point. My second son has a natural giftedness in art and also a naturally unmotivated personality. I asked him what he would like to do when he grows up and he said, "Whatever they want me to do." LOL! So I have had to insist that he continue with the art curriculum. He'll be glad later. <<<
Despite what I said to Mark just now, I agree. The real trick is to find a way to motive without force. Without giving it much thought, I'd try to find ways to tie it to something he values. I mean, how neat would it be to be able to draw pictures of the girl he wants to impress? How much fun would it be to keep a sketch journal of walks in the woods as the season's change? If he is interested in cars, he could sketch the ones he likes and then start to sketch new fantastic designs. How much easier to learn if he could illustrate points with quick sketches (a la mind maps)?
<<< Deciding when to push and when to drop these kinds of things is tough. I also don't think we should put the responsibility on our parents though. Sorry Mark! If something is a driving passion, even if you are just a child, you will beg your parents for the opportunity. Otherwise parents will let you go your own way. <<<
Yeah, that is a fine line. A kid needs some minimal exposure to find his driving passion. He does stand the best chance if home schooled, however. I remember seeing a thing on 60 Minutes, I think it was, about five farm boys in Montana or someplace and they were all students at Julliard at the top of the heap at a young age playing concerts.
>>> Mike, a sound system sounds like a great gift. Dh and I don't exchange gifts either. I love gifts, but I got tired of my dh's habit of giving me torn pieces of yellow notebook paper on Christmas morning saying, "You can buy X." LOL!! Gotta love him. <<<
Men! ROTF ;-) The trouble is that you get to know someone and, as you say below, you get stuff throughout the year. I mean, if my wife can use it today, I'm not going to wait until an official holiday ... why the hell should she wait?
>>> He lets me buy things I really want throughout the year, so it's not right for me to complain. I decided to beg the kids for the one thing I really want anyway (a Wii fitness game). <<<
Have you a Wii system now? Do you enjoy it? Have you done any comparisons with X- Box or PlayStation?
>>> I love your suggestion that a gift of doing is better. Almost everything I'm getting for the kids this year falls in that category. I'm getting lazer tag guns for everyone. The family that shoots at one another stays together, right? ;-) <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I'm going to remember that one ;-)
How the hell are you? ;-)
>>> Mike, I agree. I love the Margaritaville analogy. LOL! That's absolutely where I am. Can't wait to go to Mexico in January and try out my new Spanish speaking skills. The kids and I have been learning together using Visual Link Spanish at a nice steady clip. I've found that for my personality I can learn better with others. Actually, I learn most things best by teaching them. <<<
I'm with you there. In fact, sometimes when I get stuck on something, I imagine that I'm explaining it to someone and that often breaks the mental logjam for me.
As to Spanish, I found that listening to a Spanish radio station all day helped "work it in". There is also a wonderful TV series, called "Destinos". It is a great way to learn the language. It is done as a Spanish soap. A woman attorney is asked to help a dying man find a lover he lost many years ago. In the process, she travels to all of the various Spanish speaking countries and doing that she travels in many ways (thus discussing the words for train, boat, plane, suit case, clothing, money, etc.) It is very well done. It is one of those PBS things. Of course, if you are going in January, I'd just play the radio and TV in Spanish until you go ;-)
>>> If you had children, I suspect you would have homeschooled them. <<<
Every time I hear a news item about a teacher mollesting a child, or worse ... the kinds of idiotic politically correct crap they pass off as education ... I say just that thing.
>>> It's really the most fulfilling experience. It's an adventure in discovery. <<<
I can imagine. I can also imagine how much you learn about the world through new eyes.
>>> Just like TM systems, you can have high hopes that a curriculum will be "the answer" and then your kids say, "We hate it." lol What's fantastic about those moments is that you usually hate it, too. My oldest was asking why he had to keep using the art curriculum when he doesn't like it and doesn't plan to do anything with it in the future. I found myself saying, "Because I had to do it." He didn't even have to say anything before I realized that I needed to let him scrap it. <<<
LOL ;-) That IS neat.
>>> Now to Mark's point. My second son has a natural giftedness in art and also a naturally unmotivated personality. I asked him what he would like to do when he grows up and he said, "Whatever they want me to do." LOL! So I have had to insist that he continue with the art curriculum. He'll be glad later. <<<
Despite what I said to Mark just now, I agree. The real trick is to find a way to motive without force. Without giving it much thought, I'd try to find ways to tie it to something he values. I mean, how neat would it be to be able to draw pictures of the girl he wants to impress? How much fun would it be to keep a sketch journal of walks in the woods as the season's change? If he is interested in cars, he could sketch the ones he likes and then start to sketch new fantastic designs. How much easier to learn if he could illustrate points with quick sketches (a la mind maps)?
<<< Deciding when to push and when to drop these kinds of things is tough. I also don't think we should put the responsibility on our parents though. Sorry Mark! If something is a driving passion, even if you are just a child, you will beg your parents for the opportunity. Otherwise parents will let you go your own way. <<<
Yeah, that is a fine line. A kid needs some minimal exposure to find his driving passion. He does stand the best chance if home schooled, however. I remember seeing a thing on 60 Minutes, I think it was, about five farm boys in Montana or someplace and they were all students at Julliard at the top of the heap at a young age playing concerts.
>>> Mike, a sound system sounds like a great gift. Dh and I don't exchange gifts either. I love gifts, but I got tired of my dh's habit of giving me torn pieces of yellow notebook paper on Christmas morning saying, "You can buy X." LOL!! Gotta love him. <<<
Men! ROTF ;-) The trouble is that you get to know someone and, as you say below, you get stuff throughout the year. I mean, if my wife can use it today, I'm not going to wait until an official holiday ... why the hell should she wait?
>>> He lets me buy things I really want throughout the year, so it's not right for me to complain. I decided to beg the kids for the one thing I really want anyway (a Wii fitness game). <<<
Have you a Wii system now? Do you enjoy it? Have you done any comparisons with X- Box or PlayStation?
>>> I love your suggestion that a gift of doing is better. Almost everything I'm getting for the kids this year falls in that category. I'm getting lazer tag guns for everyone. The family that shoots at one another stays together, right? ;-) <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I'm going to remember that one ;-)
Reply by Mark Forster
I'm going to close this thread now as it's become too large to be manageable. You are welcome to continue the discussion on a new thread.